Fox chief: ‘American Idol’s’ problem is talent pool, not judges

SHARE Fox chief: ‘American Idol’s’ problem is talent pool, not judges

Fox’s one-time ratings juggernaut “American Idol” has watched its ratings plummet in recent years, with a mere 6.6 million viewers tuning in for the first part of last season’s finale that saw Caleb Johnson crowned the winner.

Mind you, 6.6 million is still a good number for the vast majority of TV shows — but not for “Idol,” which used to average 30 million viewers in its heyday. The first half of the finale marked the lowest-rated episode in the long life of the singing competition that will begin its 14th season next spring.

Fox Networks Group chair Peter Rice told TV critics Sunday that the show “is aging gracefully,” but he acknowledged that the series needs a shot in the arm when it comes to contestants.

“We haven’t found in the last two years a group of kids who’ve captured the imagination of the public,” Rice said. (The last real star the show produced was in 2012 with Phillip Phillips, yet the show’s general trend of eroding ratings pre-dates Phillips.)

Rice said the show decided not to tinker with the judges’ panel — made up of Jennifer Lopez, Keith Urban and Harry Connick, Jr. — because fan feedback on the trio was positive.

As was previously reported, when the show returns next spring it will likely be pared back from the usual 50-plus hours to a leaner 37.

The Latest
Los comisionados apoyaron mayoritariamente el envío de dinero en efectivo a la Municipalidad, pero expresaron su preocupación por asegurarse que utilicen el dinero para el uso que está destinado.
Columnist Gene Lyons was out for a few weeks after he was diagnosed with several illnesses. Now that he’s back in the saddle, he writes about what felt like a near-death experience and aging.
Other poll questions: Do you wish Tim Anderson were still with the White Sox? And how sure are you that Caleb Williams is the best QB in next week’s NFL draft?
William Dukes Jr. was acquitted of the 1993 killings of a Cicero woman and her granddaughter after a second trial in 2019. In 2022, he was arrested in an unrelated sexual assault case in Chicago.
An NFL-style two-minute warning was also OK’d.