Editorial: A pardon for Snowden puts cart before the horse

SHARE Editorial: A pardon for Snowden puts cart before the horse
snowden_pardon_64033409.jpg

Dinah PoKempner, left, general council for Human Rights Watch, listens as Edward Snowden speaks on a television screen via video link from Moscow during a Wednesday news conference to call upon President Barack Obama to pardon Snowden before he leaves office. Human and civil rights organizations, including the ACLU, Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, launched a public campaign to persuade Obama to pardon the former National Security Agency contractor. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer)

Follow @csteditorialsCome on home, Edward Snowden, and stand trial. Explain to your fellow Americans in open court how it is that you are a whistleblower and not a criminal.

Only then, if and when you are convicted, should any president consider granting you a pardon.

Last week, several of the world’s most respected human rights and civil rights groups, including the ACLU and Amnesty International, launched a new campaign to encourage President Obama to pardon Snowden, who in 2013 leaked state secrets. Snowden, now holed up in Russia, revealed classified documents that showed how the National Security Agency conducts a secret global surveillance program.

There is no question Snowden — made out to be a hero in a new movie directed by Oliver Stone — did our nation a great deal of good. Americans were alarmed to learn just how extensively our government, without judicial warrants, pried into the phone calls, emails and other records of ordinary citizens. In 2014, Congress rewrote a law to reduce incursions on privacy, and everyone from citizens to businesses has been more cautious about protecting privacy.

EDITORIAL

Follow @csteditorialsBut the truth remains that we live in a dangerous world, and the surveillance work of the National Security Agency and the Central Intelligence Agency remains essential to our national security. To think otherwise is naive. And while our snoops must be reined in and monitored by laws and courts, the legitimate work they do would become impossible if any government employee or contractor — such as Snowden — felt free to reveal state secrets as he or she saw fit.

That can never be their call.

Obama and presidential candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald J. Trump all say Snowden does not deserve a pardon at this time.

Trials come first and pardons later, if at all.

Follow the Editorial Board on Twitter: @csteditorials

Tweets by @CSTeditorials

The Latest
The first route is planned between the airport and the Illinois Medical District.
Florence Pugh, Morgan Freeman star in contrived, heavy-handed and tragedy-soaked drama from writer-director Zach Braff.
No one likes playing the victim more than Trump. But it’s no badge of honor for his standing if Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg files criminal charges against him.
Cole played a whopping 74 percent of the Titans’ special teams snaps last season — a figure that’s in line with the way he found his niche in the NFL.
In this weekend’s shows, he’ll stage “Francis Comes Alive,” that will see him attempt to create a live album a la the great “Frampton Comes Alive!”