Illinois fish records keep falling: DNA could prove tiger muskie

SHARE Illinois fish records keep falling: DNA could prove tiger muskie

Terry Livingston Sr. with his muskie, determined by DNA testing to be a pure muskie and not the Illinois-record tiger muskie.
Credit: WLPO Facebook

Tom Kimes understands the universal draw of big fish.

‘‘Normally I would have said no, but when they said how big it was, I had to see it,’’ Kimes said about weighing Terry Livingston Sr.’s possible Illinois-record tiger muskie May 9.

A tiger muskie is a hybrid of a muskie and a northern pike.

There never has been a year like this for record fish in Illinois. Last week added to that, with Livingston’s likely tiger muskie and a record brown bullhead from Emiquon. There already have been multiple whitefish records and records for burbot and hybrid crappie.

Matt Bach caught what would have been the state-record rock bass this month, but he had to release it because it was caught at Three Oaks Recreation Area in Crystal Lake. In coming weeks, I will consider Bach’s fish — and Illinois fish records in general — and modern issues.

In the past, most grocery stores or meat markets would weigh a record fish on their certified scales. That has gotten tougher.

Livingston, a 69-year-old from Morris, knew enough about certifying an Illinois record to know he needed a certified scale. But his fish was too big to weigh on a scale at a local grocery.

In Livingston’s story, one hero is Conservation Police Officer Dave Wollgast, who thought it might be a tiger muskie.

That’s how they ended up at the Morris post office, where they took a board big enough for the fish. Kimes zeroed out the scale with the board, then weighed the 501/4-inch muskie (with a 25-inch girth) at 36 pounds, 4 ounces. That would smash the Illinois record for a tiger muskie (31-3 by Michael Behmetuik on Aug. 6, 2004, from Lake Will in Will County).

Livingston and buddy Tom Dolan were ‘‘just out making a few casts for afternoon bass’’ off an 18-foot pontoon boat at the Goose Lake subdivision in Grundy County when they saw a muskie by the boat.

The muskie eventually T-boned a 14- to 16-inch shad and kept releasing the shad to reposition it to eat it. Livingston switched to a Rooster Tail on 10- or 12-pound monofilament on an Abu Garcia baitcaster rod and reel.

One time the muskie released the shad, Livingston had made a cast close enough that the fish turned and hit. By luck, it was hooked in the upper area. After allowing it to run, Livingston brought it close for Dolan to net. But it was far bigger than the net. Livingston eventually was able to gill it and bring it in.

The fun was just beginning with certifying and weighing. Rod Thorson of radio station WLPO messaged a heads up to me.

Biologist Rob Miller checked the fish the next day and thought it was likely a tiger muskie. He cautiously took a fin clip for DNA testing but needed a pure muskie and northern pike for comparison. Biologist Frank Jakubicek was able to obtain both tissue samples for Miller from Lake County.

On Friday, Miller took the tissues to Mark Davis, a conservation biologist for the Illinois Natural History Survey in Champaign. Davis should have the results this week.

‘‘But I don’t lose either way,’’ Livingston said. ‘‘I will be happy, and my buddy will be happy. Either way, I have a fish of a lifetime.’’


Illinois hunters harvested 15,719 turkeys in the spring seasons, up from 15,484 in 2016.

Stray cast

In mid-May, is it meaner to #PerchFishingClosed or #LimpTheL, even though both are true?

Follow me on Twitter @BowmanOutside.


Really big bass from hot Plainfield South team: Fish of the Week

Illinois turkey hunters do better than last year: Harvest up slightly

The Latest
A reader from Belmont-Cragin has some ideas to make NASCAR’s upcoming street course race a true Chicago driving experience.
As automakers ponder dropping AM radio, and Congress considers stopping them, a look back on the technology’s deep roots in Chicago.
The female’s body was discovered Tuesday morning in the 9400 block of South La Salle Street, police said.
The hot dog and sausage company will invest $20 million to rehab the site, adding a second-floor office, first-floor retail space for other companies and an outdoor plaza.
Flathead catfish and other creatures of the season lead this sprawling raw-file Midwest Fishing Report.