In a recent radio interview, Illinois Comptroller and Chicago mayoral candidate Susana Mendoza took a swipe at rival Bill Daley for suggesting a new commuter tax could be one way to help the financially troubled city pay its bills.
Daley didn’t endorse the idea but only said it was worth exploring. Still, Mendoza flatly panned it on WBBM Newsradio.
“Every city that has a commuter tax — look at Detroit, Philadelphia — they are actually stagnating in terms of their economy. It’s been a job-killer,” Mendoza said. “This is just, again, going back to an easy well that panders to a public that doesn’t understand the real ramifications of what these ill-fated policies will do.”
The sweeping nature of her statement caught our attention. Are commuter taxes effectively desperation moves that are doomed in the long run to hurt the economies of every city that implements them?
Commuter tax 101
It should be noted upfront that the term ‘commuter tax’ is a misleading shorthand for an array of revenue-raising schemes that affect not just those who commute to work from outside a city but city residents as well.
“The only thing that term is really conveying is that non-residents also pay the tax,” said Richard Auxier, a research associate with the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center.
Chicago once had what could loosely be referred to as a commuter tax, the so-called head tax, which levied a $4-per-worker monthly charge on larger employers. The fee was imposed regardless of whether a worker lived in or outside of Chicago.
Mayor Rahm Emanuel campaigned in 2011 to do away with the head tax, and it was eventually phased out.
Other cities with commuter taxes impose them as add-ons to local income taxes, with suburbanites who work in the city sometimes paying the same rate as city dwellers and sometimes getting a discount.
That scheme is impossible in Chicago because the state does not allow cities and counties to impose income taxes.
Not every city
Central to Mendoza’s argument is her claim that commuter taxes always backfire.
When we reached out to her campaign, spokeswoman Rebecca Evans pointed us to a 2011 Chicago inspector general report that noted how major cities with commuter taxes such as Detroit, Cleveland and Philadelphia also had stagnant economies. Evans also referenced studies of the commuter tax in Philadelphia that blame it for contributing significantly to job loss there.
However, experts we spoke with said it’s a stretch to blame the economic woes of those troubled cities on their commuter taxes alone.
Pointing to the decline of Detroit and Cleveland, Auxier said the commuter tax was likely just one factor amid larger manufacturing and population trends sweeping the Rust Belt.
It’s possible, he acknowledged, that the tax could have aggravated an already bad situation by helping to nudge businesses and residents out of the city. “But (the commuter tax is) often a reaction to some of these other, larger issues that are going on,” he said.
Philadelphia’s commuter tax, for instance, was implemented in 1939 as the city sought to avoid bankruptcy in the wake of the Great Depression.
Evans told us Mendoza doesn’t claim that in every city with a commuter tax it is the sole source of economic difficulties. But she stuck by her candidate’s claim that cities with such taxes all suffer from economic problems.
The problem with that sweeping generalization is that some U.S. cities with commuter taxes are thriving.
Employment in Denver is up more than 60 percent since 1990, according to census data. The unemployment rate currently sits at 3.3 percent, below the national average.
What’s more, the average weekly wage in the Denver metro area, which includes both Denver and its adjacent suburb of Aurora with a similar head tax, ranked 8th highest in the nation in 2017. And Denver added nearly 3,000 new businesses between 2007 and 2016.
Louisville, Kentucky, and Columbus, Ohio, are other large, financially healthy cities that impose commuter taxes.
“I think you should always be careful with these taxes, and there’s good reason to not make this your first choice,” Auxier said. “But there’s plenty of successful cities that have these taxes.”
Mendoza said every city with a commuter tax is stagnating economically under a tax that’s been a job-killer.
Mendoza isn’t wrong to point out that commuter taxes carry the risk of discouraging business and employment in a city, and have been proven to do so in select cases, such as that of Philadelphia.
But she didn’t stop there. Instead, she contended that because some cities with commuter taxes are underperforming economically, all cities with such taxes must be doing badly as well. That is simply not the case.
We rate her claim Mostly False.
TheBetter Government AssociationrunsPolitiFact Illinois, the local arm of the nationally renowned, Pulitzer Prize-winning fact-checking enterprise that rates the truthfulness of statements made by governmental leaders and politicians. BGA’s fact-checking service has teamed up weekly with the Sun-Times, in print and online. You can find all ofthe PolitiFact Illinois stories we’ve reported togetherhere.
Radio interview: Susana Mendoza, WBBM News Radio, Jan. 6, 2019
“Bill Daley opens door to commuter tax to help fund pensions,” Chicago Sun-Times, Nov. 28, 2018
Email and phone interview: Richard Auxier, research associate with the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Jan. 8 – 10
“City Council votes to eliminate ‘head tax,’” Chicago Tribune, Nov. 2, 2011
Email interview: Rebecca Evans, Mendoza spokeswoman, Jan. 9 – 10, 2019
Report: Budget Options for the City of Chicago, Chicago Inspector General, September 2011
“Philly’s city wage tax just turned 75. Here’s its dubious legacy,” Technical.ly, Dec. 12, 2014
“Commuter tax has driven jobs out of the city,” The Philadelphia Inquirer, April 24, 2006
Report: Local income taxes continue to wane, Tax Foundation, Aug. 31, 2011
“Hickenlooper’s criticism of higher fees isn’t in line with his budget for Denver,” The Denver Post, March 19, 2010
Data: Local Area Unemployment Statistics, U.S. Census, accessed Jan. 10, 2019
“The economies of the 40 biggest U.S. cities, ranked from worst to best,” Business Insider, June 20, 2018
Interactive map: Change in business establishments between 2007 and 2016, Economic Innovation Group
Phone interview: David Merriman, professor of public finance at the University of Illinois-Chicago, Jan. 8, 2019
Phone interview: John Yinger, trustee professor of public administration and economics at Syracuse University, Jan. 10, 2019
Email interview: Katherine Loughead, policy analyst at the Tax Foundation, Jan. 7 – 10, 2019