Florida student faces charges after refusing to stand for Pledge of Allegiance

SHARE Florida student faces charges after refusing to stand for Pledge of Allegiance

First Amendment rights prevent schools from requiring students to recite the pledge or salute the flag, the Supreme Court ruled in 1943. | AP Photos

An 11-year-old student in Florida is facingcharges after refusingto stand for the Pledge of Allegiance and creatingadisturbance in the classroom, police said.

The boywas arrested for causing a disruption and refusing repeated instructions from school staff and law enforcement,Polk County Public Schools spokespersonKyle Kennedy said in a statement. He was not arrested for refusing to participate in the pledge– even thoughstudents have the right to do so byFlorida lawand district policy.

The sixth-grader from a Tampa suburb allegedly told his substitute teacher the flag is “racist” and the national anthem is offensive to black people,Bay News 9 reported, citing a statement the teacher gave the district.

In response, the teacher said she asked the student why not go to another place to live if it was “so bad here.” She said he answered,“They brought me here.”

The substitute, identified by district officials as Ana Alvarez, said, “Well, you can always go backbecause I came here from Cuba and the day I feel I’m not welcome here anymore, I would find another place to live.”

Alvarez said she called the office on Feb. 4 because she did not want to keep “dealing with him,” according to her statement. An officer and a school administrator tried to calm the student,the Lakeland Police Department said in a Sunday night press release. The administratorasked him to leave the classroom more than 20 times, police said, and the studentallegedly made threats while being escorted to the office.

Police transported the Lawton Chiles Middle Academy studentto the Juvenile Assessment Center and charged him withdisrupting a school function and resisting an officerwithout violence, the Lakeland Police Department said.

Officers would not arrest a studentfor not standing during the Pledge of Allegiance, public information officer Gary Gross told USA TODAY on Sunday, but, in general, would arrest a student for screaming, yelling and making threats.

Dhakira Talbot, the boy’s mother, told Bay News 9 that she wants the charges dropped. She deniedthe arrest affidavit accusing her son of threatening to beat the teacher, the station reported.

“She was wrong. She was way out of place,” Talbot told Bay News 9. “If she felt like there was an issue with my son not standing for the flag, she should’ve resolved that in a way different manner than she did.”

Alvarez no longer works as a substitute in the district, Kennedy said, adding that the teacher did not know students weren’t required to participate in the pledge. The district will also review training for substitutes, Kennedy said.

First Amendment rights preventschools from requiring students to recite the pledge or salute the flag, the Supreme Court ruled in 1943.

The Latest
Billy Donovan wants to see aggressiveness from Williams, the fourth overall pick in 2020. He needs to adjust his pass-first mentality and attack more.
Cubs manager David Ross said he’s eager to pick High-A South Bend manager Lance Rymel’s brain about rules changes when he meets with the big-league team in Chicago.
Timeline tight to get bills out in time for property owners to claim a hefty deduction with the IRS.
Donald “Lil’ Don” Lee faces racketeering conspiracy charges in a trial that is expected to last several weeks and take jurors deep into the world of the Wicked Town street gang.
“Railroaders,” a joint project of the Chicago History Museum and the Center for Railroad Photography & Art, is on display at through the end of the year at Pullman Exhibit Hall.