Bears’ QB battle in Matt Nagy’s hands

With no preseason games to determine a winner between Mitch Trubisky and Nick Foles, it could be up to Nagy’s intuition and feel to make the right call. Do you trust him?

SHARE Bears’ QB battle in Matt Nagy’s hands
Getting the quarterback right in 2020 — Mitch Trubisky or Nick Foles will battle it out — will be a key test for Bears coach Matt Nagy (left) and general manager Ryan Pace.

Getting the quarterback right in 2020 — Mitch Trubisky or Nick Foles will battle it out — will be a key test for Bears coach Matt Nagy (left) and general manager Ryan Pace.

Tim Boyle/For the Sun-Times

Coach Matt Nagy seems to know he picked the wrong year to have an open competition at quarterback.

“It’s not easy, but it’s going to get done,” Nagy said when asked about choosing Mitch Trubisky or Nick Foles without the benefit of preseason games because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Even in normal times, picking a starting quarterback before the start of the regular season is rife with the potential for false positives — especially with the preseason devolving in recent seasons into a battleground to pick the bottom half of the roster.

But at least that was real football, as close to regular-season full speed as you’re going to get. Without it, Nagy is left with practice reps and modified scrimmages — mostly against second- and third-teamers — to determine the Trubisky vs. Foles battle. Practice is a famously poor indicator of game-day performance. That was never more evident than last year against the Saints when Trubisky missed an early third-down throw to an open Taylor Gabriel and lamented afterward, “I hit that every single time this week in practice.”

Nagy is aware of how specious that part of the process can be, so he’s determined to alter it to provide a better measuring stick.

“We have a method to the madness,” Nagy said. “We need to be creative within these drills and make sure the time that’s given to us, that we’re using it as much as we can with competitive periods.

“It’s hard to do that in walkthroughs. It’s hard to do that in meetings, even when they’re in person. But when we get a chance to go out there, we’re evaluating those quarterbacks with every single play — not just throw, but every single check they make at the line of scrimmage, every bit of leadership they show in and out of the huddle, and we’re watching how they react to a specific play in practice.”

What that likely means is that Nagy and his quarterback-centric offensive staff are going to come in handy more than ever this season because intuition and feel will be more vital than completions, touchdowns and any other measurables in training camp.

Since general manager Ryan Pace signed Mike Glennon in free agency and drafted Trubisky over others, the Bears have added a significant amount of quarterback knowledge — Nagy, quarterbacks coach John DeFilippo and offensive coordinator Bill Lazor.

Trubisky has played — and sounded — like a quarterback with too many voices in his ear, but in this situation, the more quarterback expertise on the Bears’ coaching staff, the better. Nagy is nearly as open-minded as he is self-confident — two vital traits with a decision like this in the balance.

“Our coordinators are doing a heck of a job figuring out ways to maximize those competitive plays and periods,” Nagy said. “We feel confident that we believe it’ll all play itself out. I’ll be completely open, and we’ll just take it day by day.”

Nagy acknowledged that Foles is at a disadvantage because of the limitations on the offseason schedule caused by the coronavirus.

“Nick knows that,’’ Nagy said. ‘‘He’s a smart guy. But at the same time, I think he’ll be hungry to get back out there and prove it on the field and try to build up those relationships he lost.”

But, wait, there’s more. The Bears also have holdover assistant Dave Ragone, a Trubisky confidant bumped from quarterbacks coach to passing-game coordinator in the offseason. And then there’s Pace, whose record in quarterback evaluation is dubious but will have a voice in the matter as GM.

“The good thing with Matt is it’s constant dialogue,” Pace said. “Constant communication, constant collaboration between him and I and his coaching staff. It’ll be a collaborative decision.”

That’s how the Bears do everything, of course. But at this point, Pace has to know that, ultimately, this needs to be Nagy’s call.

The Latest
Other poll questions: Do you wish Tim Anderson were still with the White Sox? And how sure are you that Caleb Williams is the best QB in next week’s NFL draft?
William Dukes Jr. was acquitted of the 1993 killings of a Cicero woman and her granddaughter after a second trial in 2019. In 2022, he was arrested in an unrelated sexual assault case in Chicago.
An NFL-style two-minute warning was also OK’d.
From Connor Bedard to Lukas Reichel, from Alex Vlasic to Arvid Soderblom, from leadership to coaching, the Hawks’ just-finished season was full of both good and bad signs for the future.
Hundreds gathered for a memorial service for Cook County Clerk Karen Yarbrough, a mysterious QR code mural enticed Taylor Swift fans on the Near North Side, and a weekend mass shooting in Back of the Yards left 9-year-old Ariana Molina dead and 10 other people wounded, including her mother and other children.