Despite Robin Lehner’s struggles, goalie switch in shootouts not on the table for Blackhawks

Lehner’s loss Saturday dropped his career record in shootouts to 8-22. Corey Crawford, meanwhile, is 31-23 all time. But history shows switching goalies just for shootouts to be an unwise idea.

SHARE Despite Robin Lehner’s struggles, goalie switch in shootouts not on the table for Blackhawks
Blackhawks_Stars_Hockey.jpg

Robin Lehner admitted he’s “not very good” at shootouts after Saturday’s loss.

Tony Gutierrez/AP

Among all NHL goaltenders, Robin Lehner has the best regular save percentage — and the second-worst shootout save percentage.

Lehner has allowed four goals on five shootout attempts, including goals by Joe Pavelski and Tyler Seguin in Saturday’s 2-1 loss to the Stars.

He has been a terrible shootout goalie throughout his career with an 8-22 record and .521 save percentage across his stints with the Senators, Sabres, Islanders and Blackhawks.

The league-average save percentage in shootouts, by comparison, is .683 over the last six seasons and .707 this season.

The always-honest Lehner is fully aware of those woes.

“I’m not very good at them,” he said Saturday. “I don’t know what’s tough about them or not tough about them. I just don’t seem to make the save in the shootout, and I do on the breakaways. It’s a little bit different in speed for me. I’ve tried to do a bunch of different things.”

Corey Crawford, meanwhile, has above-average shootout results during his career, even though he was tagged for two goals on three attempts in the loss to the Penguins earlier this month. Crawford is 31-23 all time with a .719 save percentage.

Crawford_shootout.jpg

Corey Crawford has been solid in shootouts throughout his career, although he lost to the Penguins a few weeks ago.

AP Photos

With the Hawks clearly struggling in the shootout lately — they’re 0-3 after going 3-1 last season and 52-40 dating to 2009 — they must consider all options to gain those valuable extra points. 

At least their shootout scoring should improve over the long run. Jonathan Toews (boasting his excellent 47 percent career scoring mark) and Patrick Kane (a solid 37 percent) will convert more often than their 1-for-3 marks so far.

The shootout goaltending is a bigger question, though. 

One obvious but drastic possibility would be subbing Crawford in for Lehner, regardless of how Lehner plays in the preceding 65 minutes of real hockey (and in both of Lehner’s shootouts this season, he has played incredibly beforehand, making 40 saves on 41 shots against the Stars and 33 saves on 34 shots against the Golden Knights on Oct. 22).

But coach Jeremy Colliton said he’s adamantly opposed to that idea.

“That’d be tough,” Colliton said. “Listen, Robin played really well. I don’t think it’s fair to talk about the shootout, as well as he played for the rest of the 65 minutes. He was really good.”

NHL rules allow for pre-shootout (albeit not in-shootout) goalie changes, and it has been tried at least a few times before, but history is on Colliton’s side.

In October 2008, then-Maple Leafs coach Ron Wilson switched starter Vesa Toskala, a horrendous shootout goalie who had already lost two other shootouts that month, for backup Curtis Joseph, a good shootout goalie, in a game against the Ducks. 

But Joseph allowed goals on both Ducks attempts, and the Leafs lost anyway.

In an Islanders-Penguins matchup in October 2011, Rick DiPietro replaced Isles starter Evgeni Nabokov for the shootout. An explanation was never given, but DiPietro finished his career .730 in shootouts, while Nabokov finished at .645, so it may well have been strategic. 

But the Isles also lost despite DiPietro stopping two of three attempts.

The obvious challenge of a goalie entering the game cold, with only a few minutes to prepare, and immediately facing uncontested breakaways with the game on the line apparently overrides goalies’ overall shootout tendencies.

So the Hawks likely will ride with Lehner in future situations and hope for the best.

The Latest
Alex Caruso has been looking for a defensive showing like the one he and his teammates put on display in the win over the Pacers, but Caruso also knows it needs staying power. Could Javonte Green help that process moving forward?
Christian I. Soto, 22, was charged with murder, attempted murder and home invasion, officials announced Thursday. Rockford Police Chief Carla Redd said earlier investigators haven’t determined a motive for the attacks.
Can a message generated by an algorithm ever match hearing from a human?
White Sox fans from all over will flock to Guaranteed Rate Field on Thursday for the team’s home opener against the Tigers.
Despite the addition of some new characters (human and otherwise) the film comes across as a relatively uninspired and fairly forgettable chapter in the Monsterverse saga.