Fact-check: Congress hopeful’s paycheck claim bounces

Marie Newman, who says she wants a rematch with Rep. Dan Lipinski in next year’s Democratic primary, said during a recent radio interview that the Southwest Side and southwest suburban 3^rd Congressional District needs a representative who understands how tough it is for voters to make ends meet.

And to underscore the gravity of that financial pressure, Newman, who lost to Lipinski in 2018, cited an eye-popping statistic.

“We’re in a situation right now where 80% of the country is living paycheck to paycheck, and that is not acceptable,” she told WCPT, a talk radio station in Chicago.

Democrats increasingly warn of a growing wealth gap between rich and poor. Still, 80% living paycheck to paycheck sounded shockingly high, so we decided to take a closer look.

Missing context

We asked Newman’s campaign where her number came from, and a spokesman sent several news articles all linking back to an online survey conducted for the CareerBuilder employment website.

A CareerBuilder press release describes the results of its survey, conducted among adults working full-time for private sector companies between 2016 and 2017 by the Harris Poll. The press release breaks down the numbers in a way Newman did not: 38% of employees said they sometimes live paycheck to paycheck, 17% said they usually do and 23% said they always do.

But Kreg Steven Brown, an Urban Institute research associate who studies economic opportunity, said it was “imprecise at best” to include the nearly 40% of people who report only “sometimes” living paycheck to paycheck in the grand total.

To be clear, that’s not on Newman alone. Both CareerBuilder and many of the articles that cite the survey also stressed that total over the specific breakdown.

There are other problems with taking the 80% (78%, to be precise) total at face value. The CareerBuilder release, for instance, does not spell out the questions posed in its survey, leaving it unclear what participants were asked to consider when evaluating whether they were indeed “living paycheck to paycheck.”

Polling experts we spoke with said that sort of detail is critical to evaluating the quality of survey results.

“If you’re asking people to look at a percentage of any kind without providing a way for people to also get access to the underlying information about data collection, you’re really asking people to take something on faith,” said Nora Cate Schaeffer, vice president of the American Association for Public Opinion Research.

We contacted CareerBuilder asking for more information about their 2017 survey. A spokeswoman told us the site no longer keeps it.

What other surveys say

The 80% paycheck to paycheck claim seems even more questionable when laid up against the results of other public opinion surveys that have asked similar questions.

Indeed, a 2014 poll of Harris, the same organization that conducted the later poll for CareerBuilder, found that 46% of unretired U.S. adults say they “live paycheck to paycheck and can’t afford to put money in savings.”

A recent Urban Institute report analyzed survey data from 2017 and found 32% of non-elderly U.S. adults had experienced some form of financial distress in the previous 12 months.

A survey included in the U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s 2017 report on financial well-being asked respondents whether they “have difficulty making ends meet” and found that 43% of U.S. adults said they had.

And a survey conducted for a similar 2017 report from the Federal Reserve found that four in 10 adults, if faced with an unexpected $400 expense, would not be able to cover it or would have to sell something or borrow in order to do so. That fact has been cited — with varying degrees of accuracy — in several other claims PolitiFact recently fact-checked.

As described in the CareerBuilder release, its survey sampled a subset of U.S. adults who are not yet retired. Experts said that might help explain why the results seemed off from similar polls that queried a broader range of respondents.

Our ruling

Newman said, “we’re in a situation right now where 80% of the country is living paycheck to paycheck.”

Her claim traces back to the results of a 2017 survey commissioned by a jobs site that provided scant details beyond the alarming topline numbers. The site also noted, however, that 38% of those respondents said they lived paycheck to paycheck “sometimes” rather than “usually” or “always.”

Surveys asking similar questions in recent years have yielded results about financial distress that may still seem troubling but were nowhere as severe as the numbers highlighted by CareerBuilder and echoed by Newman.

Newman’s claim accurately reflects the single survey she is relying on, but it appears to be an outlier among similar polls. We rate Newman’s claim Half True.

HALF TRUE – The statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context.

Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check

Editor’s note: A previous version of this fact-check misstated an Urban Institute expert’s name. It has been updated to reflect that his name is Kreg Steven Brown.

The Better Government Association runs PolitiFact Illinois, the local arm of the nationally renowned, Pulitzer Prize-winning fact-checking enterprise that rates the truthfulness of statements made by governmental leaders and politicians. BGA’s fact-checking service has teamed up weekly with the Sun-Times, in print and online. You can find all of the PolitiFact Illinois stories we’ve reported together here.

Sources

Radio interview: Marie Newman, WCPT, April 24, 2019

“78% Of Workers Live Paycheck To Paycheck,” Forbes, Jan. 11, 2019

“The government shutdown spotlights a bigger issue: 78% of US workers live paycheck to paycheck,” CNBC, Jan. 9, 2019

Press release, CareerBuilder, Aug. 24, 2017

Email interview: Kreg Steven Brown, research associate at the Urban Institute, April 26, 2019

Phone interview: Kathleen Weldon, director of data operations and communications at Cornell University’s Roper Center for Public Opinion Research, April 25, 2019

Phone interview: Nora Cate Schaeffer, vice president of the American Association for Public Opinion Research and faculty director at the University of Wisconsin Survey Center, April 26, 2019

Email interview: Stephanie Rosenblum, CareerBuilder spokeswoman, April 26, 2019

Press release, The Harris Poll, July 10, 2014

Report: Financial well-being in America, U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, September 2017

Report: Financial Distress Among American Families, Urban Institute, February 2019

Report: Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2017, Federal Reserve, May 2018

“An unexpected $400 expense would be damaging for many, but Kamala Harris overstates report’s finding,” PolitiFact California, April 19, 2019

“Checking Howard Schultz’s claim that 40 percent of Americans don’t have $400 in the bank,” PolitiFact, Jan. 29, 2019

Email interview: Abdur Chowdhury, professor emeritus of economics at Marquette University, April 26, 2019

Email interview: Jonathan J. Morduch, professor of public policy and economics at the Wagner Graduate School of Public Service at New York University, April 25, 2019

Email interview: Daniel Schneider, professor of sociology at University of California at Berkeley, April 25, 2019