The intellectual dishonesty of Trumpists’ foreign, domestic culture wars

The president has talked about destroying Iranian cultural sites. His propagandists want us to believe that when others destroy culture, it’s bad, but when we do it, it’s good.

SHARE The intellectual dishonesty of Trumpists’ foreign, domestic culture wars
Trump Campaign Launches “Evangelicals For Trump” Coalition In Miami

President Donald Trump speaks during an ‘Evangelicals for Trump’ campaign event at a Miami church on Jan. 3, 2020.

Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images

One morning, back in August of 2017, the gang on “Fox & Friends,”President Trump’sfavorite news program, was in the midst of a feverish MAGA panic over nothing less than “the eradication of history,” asLaura Ingrahamcalled it.

It was just days after theCharlottesville, Virginiaprotests, a violent and, in one tragic case, fatal clash between white supremacists and counter-protesters in which many of the former chanted slogans like “white lives matter” and “Jews will not replace us.”

Nevertheless, Trump had insisted, “Many of those people were there to protest the taking down of the statue ofRobert E. Lee.”

”When you see bands of criminals, which is what they were yesterday, ripping down public property and being celebrated in the American media for doing so, we have a real problem on our hands,” seethed Ingraham on Fox.

Columnists bug

Columnists


In-depth political coverage, sports analysis, entertainment reviews and cultural commentary.

”How long,” she continued, “before they show up at Monticello, where I spent three years in law school atCharlottesvilleinVirginia? How long before they show up atMount Vernon?”

”OrMount Rushmore,” addedPete Hegseth.

The left’s persistent efforts to supposedly rewrite America’s sometimes ugly history has become such a cornerstone of Fox’s culture war coverage that more than a year later, Ingraham was talking about the destruction of Confederate statues again, this time, using even stronger language. “This recalls the kind of destructive mindset of let’s say,ISIS,” she said inDecember 2018. “Think aboutISIS, what they did, they pillaged and they wiped away irreplaceable historical and religious monuments. FromPalmyra— remember, inSyria? —simply because they could.”

In the wake of theU.S.killing of Iranian Maj.Gen. Qassem SoleimaniinIraq,President Trumphas threatened to target 52 Iranian sites if that country retaliates, “some at a very high level & important toIran& the Iranian culture,” he tweeted. Even as administration officials distanced themselves from the threat, he then reiterated it.

Never mind that the intentional targeting of cultural sites is an unambiguous war crime under the 1954Hague Convention— which is likely why Secretary of StateMike Pompeoand Secretary of DefenseMark Esperhave publicly attempted to rule that out. At least one Fox friend was suddenly unconcerned with this particular culture war.

”I don’t care about Iranian cultural sites, and I’ll tell you why,”Pete Hegsethsaid Monday night. “If you understand theIslamic Republic of Iran, of Islamists, if they could come, if they had the power, they would destroy every single one of our cultural sites and build a mosque on top of it.”

Trump’s propagandists are known for many things. Intellectual consistency is not one of them. (Just ask them what they now think of American intelligence now that Trump is using it to justify the drone strike.) What we are genuinely being asked to believe is that when the American left destroys cultural sites like Confederate monuments, it’s bad.

WhenISISdestroys cultural sites inSyria, it’s really bad. WhenIranmight do it, it’s triple-dog bad. But when Trump proposes it, it is right and just.

There are many reasons why destroying a culture’s important and unique history is an abominable idea. For one, as the late British scholarPaul Connertonwrote in “How Societies Remember,” the erasure of cultural memory is a technique perfected by totalitarian regimes, an act of “mental enslavement” and “forced forgetting” perpetrated against myriad societies throughout history, from the Jews in NaziGermanyto the Caucasus in the 2000s. We should not align with this worldview.

For another, destroying the sites, some of which are revered by perhaps 1.9 billion Islamic people around the world — or 25% of the population — is not only illegal and undemocratic, but likely a very bad political idea. If the president claims to love the Iranian people, bombing their shrines and statues hardly conveys that to them, or other Iranians and Muslims around the world.

Finally, the Islamic extremism espoused by Soleimani, as well as any other kind of extremist ideology, is dangerous and odious not just because of its indiscriminate violence, but because it attempts to erode and erase entire cultures. Trump’s explicit interest in attacking Iranian culture reeks of the very same extremism he and his cohorts routinely and rightly denounce.

It’s also antithetical to his promise to end “forever wars” and reverseGeorge W. Bush’sinterventionism. The opposite of nation-building is leaving a nation to its own cultural, political and structural affinities, not obliterating the ones America deems irrelevant or inherently malignant.

Here at home, what Trump’s proposal reveals is just how disingenuous his domestic culture war is. Trump’s supposed belief in the importance of national identity is a self-serving racket, a cheap trick he plays on his voters, many of whom do actually believe the parts of American culture they care about are being diminished. Preying on those anxieties wins him fans and voters, and so he does it. But destroying culture can’t only be bad when it belongs to us. And anyone who believes that cares little for the intrinsic value of culture — America’s or anyone else’s.

S.E. Cuppis the host of “S.E. Cupp Unfiltered” onCNN.

Send letters to letters@suntimes.com

The Latest
The recall includes 2019-2022 Accents, 2021-2023 Elantras and 2021-2022 Elantra HEVs. Dealerships will fit the seat belt pretensioners with a cap at no cost.
The Bulls-Pistons matchup will be the first NBA game in Europe since 2020 and the league’s 12th game in France since 1991.
All southbound lanes were closed for the investigation.
The boys are each charged with one felony count of aggravated attempted vehicular hijacking, Chicago police said.
More than 70% of applicants were women, according to statistics released by the city. Applicants are expected to receive news about their status in the program by next week.