Hope wafting up from Brazil

Defeat of election denying Jair Bolsonaro reminds us that madness comes ... and goes.

President Donald Trump (right) speaks with Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro during a dinner at Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach, Florida, on March 7, 2020.

A couple of future election losers. Jair Bolsonaro (left), president of Brazil, shares dinner with Donald Trump in March 2020, before both would-be strongmen were rejected by voters.

Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

Last weekend I flew to Texas on a quick reporting trip. As we were shuffling off the plane, it struck me how fortunate the United States is to be so big yet still a single country.

Almost a thousand miles from Chicago to Dallas. Yet no customs to go through, no passport control, no immigration lines. No reason to pause from plane door to cab stand.

That was once very different in Europe. Also about a thousand miles from London to Berlin, with the Netherlands, France and Belgium jammed between. Differing currencies, contradictory rules and burdensome duties. Time-wasting security and regulations.

Opinion bug


A lot of friction going from A to B, both people and products. Wouldn’t it be better, economically, to mimic the United States? To have one unified financial system? A European Union?

So they built one. Wasn’t easy and took years. Few liked the idea of being dictated to from Brussels about how to make cheese. Currencies that went back centuries — the franc, the lira, the mark — were abandoned for one currency, the euro. That stung.

It worked, but time passes, and things can go so well that you forget what got you there — as we saw with vaccines. And the European Union had what some considered downsides. Brits worried that Greeks or, worse, Turks, would start showing up as their neighbors in Devonshire. A movement grew to drop out of the EU, fanned by nationalists building their castles of power upon the sand of hatred.

On June 23, 2016, Britain voted, and 51.89% chose to leave the EU, 48.11% voted to stay — it’s astoundingly consistent how evenly divided the world is right now between those who want to proceed into the future and those who want to try to claw their way back into the past.

Brexit, as the departure was called, shocked me. Not that I cared particularly about the integrity of European economic systems. But because I knew that the world is a very interconnected place, and if the Brits are willing to kneecap their own economy out of local pride and racial fear, then we could, too. We had just the right toxic racist, Donald Trump, running for president, hot to do it. When Brexit was approved, I knew in my gut that Trump was going to win. Which he did, part of a rising tide of global nationalism.

Brexit supporters gather during a rally in London, on Friday, Jan. 31, 2020.

Brexit supporters gather during a rally in London on Jan. 31, 2020, the day Great Britain officially left the European Union. The margin in that 2016 referendum was less than 4 percentage points, and leaving the EU has not had the benefits many Brexit backers had hoped for.

Frank Augstein/Associated Press

Brexit’s immediate effect was to slash the United Kingdom’s GDP by 4%. The cost of the Trumpian revolution has yet to be tallied: start with a radicalized Republican Party lost in self-excusing hallucination, growing violence and opposition to any democratic norm that might check their power: elections, the media, factuality. No way of knowing what the price will ultimately be, but a 4% blow to the economy looks like a bargain.

That’s the bad news. The good news is things change, and the same winds that warned of our own impending disaster can also bring the whiff of hope. On Sunday, in Brazil, president Jair Bolsonaro, the “Trump of the Tropics,” lost the election to progressive former president Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva. 50.9% to 49.1% — again, that near-even split.

True, Bolsonaro, who parroted Trump that any election he loses is by definition fraudulent, hasn’t conceded and probably won’t. His supporters are calling for a coup, mirroring the Jan. 6 insurrection. Expect trouble.

Argentina’s President Alberto Fernandez (left) and Brazil’s President-elect Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva pose for pictures during a meeting in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on October 31, 2022.

Jair Bolsonaro may not have conceded defeat in the Brazilian presidential election, but other countries are already acknowledging Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva’s victory. Here, the president of Argentina, Alberto Fernandez (left) meets in Sao Paulo, Brazil, with da Silva, who defeated Bolsonaro on Sunday.

Nelson Almeida/AFP via Getty Images

But Bolsonaro is on his way out, whether he goes graciously or clinging to the doorframe and howling like Trump did. You can only fool people so long. Realization dawns.

“What have we done?” one British businessman told the Guardian, explaining how he voted for Brexit hoping for a more dynamic nation, only to see trade go “completely bonkers.”

“Completely bonkers” is now on deck in America. The midterms are next week. Nate Silver is predicting an 82% chance of a Republican return to power in the House and a 50-50 chance of their retaking the Senate — with all the craziness (expect Biden to be impeached for faking the moon landing) that will ensue.

But the tide that comes in also goes out, eventually. The really bad part hasn’t yet come in the United States — the way the Republicans loll in fantasy, demonize their enemies and normalize violence, they are sowing seeds that will yield strange fruit. But come it will and then, if resisted with all our might, eventually go. Something to look forward to.

Supporters of former Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva celebrate his victory over incumbent Jair Bolsonaro in a presidential run-off to become the country’s next president, in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Sunday, Oct. 30, 2022.

Supporters of former Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva celebrate Sunday in Rio de Janeiro after he defeated incumbent Jair Bolsonaro in a presidential run-off to become the country’s next president.

Bruna Prado/Associated Press

The Latest
Model Chase Carter, the Cubs free agent’s fiancee, posted an image of the Toronto skyline on her Instagram this week, setting off Internet chatter that neglected to mention a fashion expo is being held in the city.
The settlement goes to the City Council for approval at Wednesday’s meeting. It would go to the children of Michael Craig, 61, who was shot and killed by police in 2021 after Craig called 911, saying his wife had “a knife on me, on the bed, on my throat.”
DE Myles Garrett and the Browns are No. 1 in yards allowed but tied 14th in points allowed — giving up 24 points or more vs. the Jaguars, Rams, Broncos and Ravens in the past five games. So it’s a challenge, but also an opportunity for Fields and Getsy.
Fields has room to grow, to be sure, but Sunday he led the Bears to their most impressive win in two years.
A las 5 a.m. del martes, los carriles en dirección sur estarán totalmente reabiertos. Una primera fase de seis meses reparó superficies, rehabilitó puentes y actualizó la pintura y las luces entre Ohio Street y el cruce de Edens.