Off-duty police officer fatally shoots dog held by neighbor, prompting lawsuit, investigation

The neighbor had pulled his dog off the officer’s dog when it was shot at point-blank range in Bridgeport.

SHARE Off-duty police officer fatally shoots dog held by neighbor, prompting lawsuit, investigation
Aggie, a medium-brown and white pit bull mix, lays on its stomach and cocks its head.

Kent Maynard’s mixed-breed pit bull, Aggie, was fatally shot by his neighbor, off-duty Chicago cop Carmen Mostek, after their dogs got into a fight April 21 in Bridgeport, according to COPA and a lawsuit.


Video released Tuesday shows an off-duty Chicago police officer shooting and killing her Bridgeport neighbor’s dog at point-blank range last month as the neighbor held the animal right after a skirmish with the officer’s corgi.

On the morning of April 21, Officer Carmen Mostek was walking her dog on a leash when her 68-year-old neighbor’s mixed-breed dog slipped out the front door and got into a fight with the corgi at 29th Street and Normal Avenue, according to the Civilian Office of Police Accountability and a federal lawsuit the neighbor filed against the officer.

Video from a neighbor’s security camera shows Mostek reaching for her firearm and not attempting to break the dogs apart as Kent Maynard runs to separate them. Maynard pulls his pet off the corgi, then falls to the ground while holding the pit bull as Mostek fires one shot, fatally striking Maynard’s dog.

Mostek’s corgi was not injured in the incident. She is seen running home with her dog after the shooting.

COPA is asking the police department to strip Mostek of her policing powers, noting in its report that Maynard’s head was “inches away” from the gunshot.

“This action raises concerns about Officer Mostek’s ability to make sound, risk-averse decisions concerning the use of deadly force as a last resort,” COPA Chief Administrator Andrea Kersten wrote. “Her decision-making in situations involving force could potentially endanger herself, members of the public and other CPD officers by exposing them to unnecessary risks and harm.”

After the shooting, Maynard can be heard on the video screaming, “You shot my dog!” and “She could’ve [expletive] shot me!”

A police report contradicts the incident shown on video, saying Mostek “attempted to get the pit bull off of her dog ... with negative results,” and that Maynard “attempted to help with negative results,” leading Mostek to fire her weapon.

In an interview with police, Mostek said Maynard’s dog “tried to kill” her dog, so she had to shoot, according to the COPA report.

Chicago police would not comment on the case or Mostek’s employment status, referring questions to COPA.

The lawsuit also says responding officers failed to interview Maynard or any witnesses and interviewed only Mostek. The police report says Maynard refused to give officers his information.

Maynard collected information from witnesses and contacted COPA investigators about the shooting, according to the lawsuit.

In the days after the shooting, neighbors sent an outpouring of condolences to Maynard and created a memorial on a sidewalk that consisted of his dog’s collar, dog toys, a photo, flowers and candles, according to the lawsuit, which also names the city and the Chicago Police Department as defendants.

“We are sorry for the loss of your beloved pet,” one note read. “We loved to see her with you! She will be missed.”

The memorial was dismantled within two days, and many of the items were found in a garbage can behind Mostek’s apartment. Community members created a second memorial, but that also was taken down and its items were found in the same garbage can, the lawsuit says.

Split image of two photos of two memorials on a sidewalk in front of a brick wall with dog toys, a dog collar, photos, candles, flowers and notes memorializing Aggie the pit bull mixed breed.

Two memorials created by neighbors of Kent Maynard for his pit bull mixed-breed dog, Aggie, who was fatally shot by an off-duty Chicago police officer in April.


A week after the shooting, Maynard’s landlord informed him that he had two weeks to move out of his apartment based on “defamatory statements” made by Mostek, the lawsuit claims.

The Latest
The crash happened about 5:30 a.m. in the 300 block of East Chicago Avenue, police said.
Three-part doc has all the dirt on music mogul’s rise and fall — and one distracting gimmick.
Two women were taken to Holy Cross Hospital with unspecified injuries and they were listed in good condition, officials said. A third woman was taken to Mount Sinai Hospital where she was also in good condition and an officer was taken to an area hospital with a “minor” foot injury. An 8-year-old girl was treated at the scene.
Doctor is helping a teacher from China relocate to U.S. and is hoping a wedding will follow.
Thinking ahead to your next few meals? Here are some main dishes and sides to try.