Polling Place: The DH in the National League? Here’s what voters have to say about that

For the first time since the American League turned to the DH in 1973, both leagues could be in sync on this oft-debated issue.

SHARE Polling Place: The DH in the National League? Here’s what voters have to say about that
St Louis Cardinals v Chicago Cubs

Somewhere, Cubs left fielder Kyle Schwarber is gnawing angrily on the leather ties of his outfielder’s glove.

Photo by Nuccio DiNuzzo/Getty Images

Somewhere, Cubs left fielder Kyle Schwarber is gnawing angrily on the leather ties of his outfielder’s glove.

We can’t prove this, but can’t you picture it? Schwarber is a proud baseball player. A proud National League baseball player. He wants to rake at the plate and try mightily to run down fly balls, and not necessarily in that order.

What Schwarber undoubtedly doesn’t want is for his glove to gather dust in the dugout while he’s in the lineup — most days — as the Cubs’ designated hitter. But there’s a pretty good chance that’s exactly what’s going to happen.

If there’s going to be baseball in 2020, one of the oddities of the season is expected to be the implementation of the universal DH. For the first time since the American League turned to the DH in 1973, both leagues would be in sync on this oft-debated issue.

But what about the fans?

For this week’s “Polling Place” — your home for Sun-Times sports polls on Twitter — we asked fans how they felt about the DH in the NL.

“You are not a ballplayer if you don’t have both a bat and a glove,” commented @aweary13.

That’s an old NL saw if we’ve ever heard one, but it doesn’t represent the results of this poll question. Most respondents were either on board with the universal DH or at least open to seeing how it shakes out.

“Whichever way it is, it should be the same for both leagues,” @debert26 wrote. “Especially with so much interleague play.”

That’s the whole reason behind it, with teams expected to be mixed — for this season only — into extra-large divisions with opponents from both the AL and NL.

On to the polls:

Poll No. 1: Where do you stand on the designated hitter being used in the National League?

Upshot: “Love it” was sure to draw a lot of votes from AL fans alone, so take this result with a grain of South Side salt. Still, this is America in 2020: If only 25% of folks hate you, you must not be that bad. Let’s let @JayZawaski670 take it from here: “There is still a part of me that likes the NL style of the game. I’m sure I won’t miss it when it’s gone, though.”

Poll No. 2: Regardless of what happens in 2020, should baseball’s playoff field be permanently expanded?

Upshot: There has been talk of up to 16 teams being included in this year’s field. Considering all the teams that are in tank mode, it might be really hard for the Cubs or Sox to miss the playoffs. Clearly, 10 is enough for our voters (and undoubtedly is too many for some). “We’re No. 16!” definitely doesn’t have much of a ring to it. As @JBIRD1268 put it, “This isn’t the NFL. Stop!”

Poll No. 3: After all the acrimony in baseball, where does your fandom stand?

Upshot: On one side of the fence sits @jkline2. “I’m out, but to be fair it’s not just this,” she commented. “It’s the Astros, Marquee, what’s happening to the minor leagues, etc.” On the other is @Chrissoxfan8, who wrote, “I haven’t been paying attention to the back-and-forth between owners [and] players, so I’m not put off by it. I just want to see my White Sox team go out there and play.” Meanwhile, how soon until that fence buckles under so much weight?

The Latest
The woman struck a pole in the 3000 block of East 106th Street, police said.
After about seven and half hours of deliberations, the jury convicted Sandra Kolalou of all charges including first-degree murder, dismembering Frances Walker’s body, concealing a homicidal death and aggravated identity theft. Her attorney plans to appeal.
Ryan Leonard continues a tradition of finding early morel mushrooms in Cook County.
During a tense vacation together, it turns out she was writing to someone about her sibling’s ‘B.S.’
A Chicago couple has invested at least $4.2 million into building a three-story yellow brick home.