Lincoln Park High School student ‘shocked’ administrator grabbed his face as tensions inside school boil over

Lincoln Park High School students stage a protest walkout and march around the building and neighborhood over the removal of school administrators and the suspension of the varsity boys basketball season, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020.

A week of turmoil led to more uproar Thursday at Lincoln Park High School as families and teachers continued to face a revolving door of administrators and coaches leaving the school under a cloud of allegations.

Students held protests throughout the day, staging a sit-in in the morning before rallying outside and marching around the school. Inside, chaos ensued after several fights between students broke out. Chicago police officers were called into the school and later put a student into a squad car, but no arrests were made. Some students left early.

Meanwhile a student said Thursday he was “shocked” and “angry” when a new administrator at Lincoln Park grabbed him by the face in an incident that was caught on video earlier in the week.

The widely circulated video showed Judith Gibbs, a retired Chicago Public Schools principal put in charge this week at Lincoln Park in the midst of the scandal, grabbing 17-year-old Jovani Muñoz in a school hallway Tuesday while asking to see his school ID card.

The incident heightened tension after the abrupt firing Friday of beloved Interim Principal John Thuet and Assistant Principal Michelle Brumfield, and the suspension of the boys basketball season. CPS officials have released broad allegations of misconduct at the school, but have not said what exactly Thuet and Brumfield did that led to their ouster.

Chicago police on Thursday confirmed they were investigating one of the incidents in question, a reported sexual assault inside a classroom after school Jan. 13. Though the case is part of what led to the upheaval at Lincoln Park, CPS hasn’t said if there was any alleged wrongdoing or mishandling of the incident by administrators.

“Students are angry,” said Ella Wong, one of the students who organized the protests. “Usually in the hallways everyone’s smiling, everyone’s happy, everyone’s talking to each other. It’s been dead quiet. Nobody’s communicating with each other. It’s really depressing to be walking through the hallway and everybody’s sad, everybody’s heads are down.

“It doesn’t feel like a real school right now. It just feels like everything is falling apart,” Wong said of the leadership vacuum. “We don’t have anything set in place, so it makes it very chaotic inside the school.”

Muñoz, a senior, said the ordeal involving Gibbs began before his first class Tuesday, when a security guard pulled him aside and asked why he wasn’t wearing his ID around his neck as per school policy. That’s when Gibbs got involved and tried to help Muñoz find a lanyard for his ID, he said.

“She reaches for my pocket and grabs my arm,” Muñoz said Thursday, recalling the incident. “Also she tries snatching it and I flinch, I pull away from it. I got nervous. And right after that she grabbed my face, and I freaked out, I was like, ‘I don’t appreciate being touched like this.’”

Muñoz said Gibbs immediately apologized after she grabbed his face, “but the shock had just gotten to me, I couldn’t just accept the apology right there.”

He added: “I went to the meeting on Monday, and their number one priority was the safety of the students. And I find that hard to believe after being grabbed by someone of such high rank, someone you allow in the building, meaning you trust them with these students.

Gibbs could not be reached for comment.

lincoln park high school sit-in protest — Lincoln Park students protest Thursday after a new administrator was caught on video grabbing a student’s face and left the school after one day.

A letter sent home to parents Wednesday from Laura LeMone, a CPS official in charge of the school network that includes Lincoln Park, said Gibbs chose to step down because she determined “she was not a good fit” for the school. The letter made no mention of the incident or the video.

“I thought it was kind of a lie,” Muñoz said of the letter.

Wong said of the incident with Gibbs that “CPS put the wrong person in our school and that’s a very big deal.”

“I hope it brings more attention to what the students are doing to show how much we need our administration back,” Wong said.

Jovani Muñoz, 17, speaks to reporters outside Lincoln Park High School, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

1 of 17

Lincoln Park High School students stage a protest walkout and march through Oz Park and the neighborhood over the removal of school administrators and the suspension of the varsity boys basketball season, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

2 of 17

A Lincoln Park High School student is escorted from the school in a Chicago Police square car after students staged protests over the removal of school administrators and the suspension of the varsity boys basketball season, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

3 of 17

Lincoln Park High School students stage a protest walkout and march around the building and neighborhood over the removal of school administrators and the suspension of the varsity boys basketball season, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

4 of 17

Charles Jackson, 17, a senior at Lincoln Park High School and player on the varsity boys basketball team, speaks to reporters outside the building, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

5 of 17

Lincoln Park High School students ignore Chicago Police officers’ requests to stay on the sidewalk as they protest and march around the neighborhood over the removal of school administrators and the suspension of the varsity boys basketball season, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

6 of 17

7 of 17

Jovani Muñoz (right), 17, walks with a classmate into Lincoln Park High School after speaking to reporters outside the building, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

8 of 17

9 of 17

Chicago Police officers keep watch at Lincoln Park High School as students stage protests over the removal of school administrators and the suspension of the varsity boys basketball season, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

10 of 17

11 of 17

Ella Wong, 17, a junior at Lincoln Park High School, speaks to reporters outside the building, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

12 of 17

13 of 17

Jovani Muñoz, 17, speaks to reporters outside Lincoln Park High School, Thursday morning, Feb. 6, 2020. | Ashlee Rezin Garcia/Sun-Times

14 of 17

15 of 17

16 of 17

17 of 17

Much of the frustration and anger directed at CPS by Lincoln Park families has had to do with the minimal information that has been shared about what exactly led to the administrators’ removal, as well as the earlier suspension of head boys basketball coach Pat Gordon.

CPS officials at a meeting on Monday told families they had four investigations open at the school for allegations that included multiple instances of sexual misconduct, retaliation against witnesses, lying to families and financial mismanagement of the athletics program. But more detailed specifics weren’t given, and names weren’t attached to individual allegations.

CPS sources have said officials are worried that releasing more information could put certain students involved in the incidents in danger of being further traumatized and victimized.

But the local school council, made up of elected parents, teachers and community residents, has said even it hasn’t received any details, and was given almost no heads up that Thuet and Brumfield would be fired.

Meeting with school council canceled

The local school council was set to meet with CPS officials at 7:30 a.m. Thursday, but the district canceled that meeting Wednesday afternoon, just as news was breaking about the incident with Gibbs.

“We’re just looking for more collaboration, communication and involvement from CPS as the elected body representing students and staff and faculty and the community and parents, to make sure that we have the information to make the right decision,” said Eli Grant, a community member of the LSC.

Grant said the LSC, which has the authority to hire and renew the principal’s contract, was only told of Thuet and Brumfield’s removal minutes before the announcement last week.

“Part of what we’re really trying to understand is what they were directly involved in. And what specific things of all those allegations did they do,” Grant said. “We want the administrators back because we feel they’re positive. But if we find out more information, we want to be involved in saying, you know what, they’re not the right folks.”

In This Stream

Lincoln Park High School misconduct investigation

Lincoln Park administrator, teacher reinstated after CPS deems it ‘safe’ for them to return

CPS CEO says parents wrong to paint fired Lincoln Park H.S. leaders as victims

Ex-Lincoln Park High School administrators sue CPS, claim ‘unfounded’ allegations make them ‘virtually unemployable’

View all 13 Stories

Next Up In Education

Obama relatives sue Milwaukee school alleging racial bias

Enter the Sun-Times’ student art contest The Imagination Project with your take on ‘Spring ahead’

Pandemic-delayed memorial planned for Jan Bach, prolific composer who taught at NIU

‘Every day feels unsettled’: Why educators are burnt out these days

State asks CPS to repay $87M it mistakenly received over 3 years