Lightfoot’s extra pension payments don’t let Springfield off the hook, Civic Federation says

State laws created the police, fire, laborers and municipal employees pension funds, and state lawmakers have a responsibility to consolidate, reform and fund local pension plans, says Civic Federation President Laurence Msall.

SHARE Lightfoot’s extra pension payments don’t let Springfield off the hook, Civic Federation says
Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot came under immediate fire for comments she made before a predominantly Black audience Sunday that a vote for “somebody not named Lightfoot is a vote for Chuy Garcia or Paul Vallas,” calling out her sole Latino and white challengers by name.

Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot’s plan to include additional pension funding in her 2023 city budget won praise from Civic Federation President Laurence Msall, but he also noted the real work to fix the problem should be done in Springfield.

Ashlee Rezin/Sun-Times

Mayor Lori Lightfoot’s $242 million pension prepayment plan will prevent Chicago’s four cash-strapped pension funds from having to “sell assets in a down market” to meet obligations, but Springfield shouldn’t be let off the hook, the Civic Federation president said Tuesday.

Laurence Msall said state law was used to create the police, fire, laborers and municipal employees pension funds, and the Illinois General Assembly dictates “who the members are, what their contribution levels must be and what benefits” those retired city employees receive.

That’s why Msall believes it’s time state lawmakers live up to their responsibility to consolidate, reform and fund local pension funds to relieve Chicago and municipalities from Peoria to Rockford from the “enormous pressure” they face to raise property taxes.

Gov. J.B. Pritzker “took an important step three years ago when he rolled up many of the smaller police and fire pension funds investment oversight into one state board. The next step would be to take over the local police and fire pension funds and municipal pension funds and have the locals manage the current obligation. And the unfunded liability should be absorbed by the state,” Msall told the Sun-Times.

“If we don’t do that, then we will continue to see local governments making very difficult decisions about whether to raise property taxes to fund essential services or raise property taxes to fund more pension contributions. It is not sustainable to have 25 percent — and in some cases, even more of your operating budget — going into your pension and pension-related debt.”

Civic Federation president Laurence Msall.

Laurence Msall, president of the Civic Federation, believes state lawmakers must act on pensions. “Only the state has the broad breadth of tax potential and financial strength to take that on,” Msall said.

Rich Hein / Sun-Times file

Pressed to identify funding sources, Msall said: “Regardless of whether you’re a pensioner or a multimillionaire who has millions of dollars in investments, you pay no Illinois state income tax. The federal government taxes retirement income. Illinois is one of the few states that doesn’t tax any amount of retirement income.”

What about broadening the sales tax umbrella to include professional services or amending the Illinois Constitution to eliminate the pension protection clause?

“Certainly, those should be on the table,” Msall said.

The General Assembly, after all, put a constitutional amendment on the November ballot that, if passed, would “prevent Illinois from ever being a right-to-work state,” he said.

“Yet a constitutional amendment to address the pension crisis is almost stuck in the mud down in Springfield. Very little action on the two core issues that drive local government finances and the state’s financial health: pensions and property taxes. And both are intertwined — especially at the local level,” he said.

City audit highlights pension problem

The city’s annual audit showed how desperately Chicago still needs a long-term solution to its $33.6 billion pension crisis, even after signing off on Bally’s plans for a $1.7 billion River West casino and a temporary casino at Medinah Temple. Tax revenue from those operations is being touted as a $200 million-a-year salvation for police and fire pensions.

According to the audit, firefighters pension fund has assets to cover just 20.9% of liabilities. That’s followed by the Municipal Employees Pension Fund Fund (23.4%), police (23.5%) and laborers (45.9%).

With the mayoral election now just over four months away, Lightfoot has made virtually no long-term progress on pensions beyond the new plan to prepay $242 million in future pension debt to avoid paying “compounded interest.”

Early on, Lightfoot floated a plan for a state takeover of the four funds, but was shot down by Pritzker 

The governor subsequently made Chicago’s pension crisis infinitely worse by ignoring the mayor’s plea to veto a bill boosting pensions for thousands of Chicago firefighters. 

Lightfoot had argued it would saddle city taxpayers with perpetual property tax increases to cover $823 million in added costs by 2055 and cripple the pension fund closest to insolvency.

Other solutions to the pension crisis the mayor has floated are a sales tax on services and an increased real estate transfer tax on high-end purchases, but neither has gained traction in Springfield.

Lightfoot’s record on city employee pensions pales in comparison to that of former Mayor Rahm Emanuel, who identified dedicated revenue sources for all four funds.

He more than doubled Chicago’s property tax levy for police, fire and teacher pensions; pushed through two telephone tax hikes for the laborers pension fund and phased in a 29.5% surcharge on water and sewer bills to bankroll the municipal employees pension fund, the largest of the four.

Emanuel also persuaded the Illinois General Assembly to give Chicago Public Schools a $450 million cash infusion and bankroll teacher pensions going forward.


The Latest
Fans, some in costume, tailgate in the parking lots of Guaranteed Rate Field hours before the White Sox and Detroit Tigers kick off the 2024 seasons Thursday afternoon. Some weigh in on the proposed South Loop stadium.
Two weeks after the migrant eviction policy went into effect in Chicago, members of the Council’s Committee on Immigrant and Refugee Rights said not enough information on migrants exiting the shelter system has been provided.
Zoo officials were tipped off something was wrong after Bana stopped eating as much as she regularly did and appeared lethargic.
Mayor Brandon Johnson did not commit to spending a specific amount of public money to lakefront infrastructure improvements, but vowed that whatever public money is invested, it must be committed to creating more housing and jobs and “a sustainable, clean economy.”
Many kids in the audience came dressed up. I would recommend parents encourage it, as their youngsters will undoubtedly make new friends at intermission finding others who love the characters they do, or who identify with other ones.