Counterpoint: Lawsuit threatens future of high school football

SHARE Counterpoint: Lawsuit threatens future of high school football

IHSA Executive Director Marty Hickman says rules changes proposed in a lawsuit against the association could bring the demise of football at some schools. Photo by Seth Perlman, AP.

Editor’s note: We invited the Illinois High School Association to write a counterpoint view to our editorial. They agreed to do so, but later declined. This is the IHSA’s response to the lawsuit posted on their website.

The IHSA was founded more than 100 years ago upon the belief that participation in high school sports and activities helps make young people better citizens.


High school sports create everlasting bonds among teammates and coaches, and contribute to the fabric of communities throughout Illinois and the United States. Working in conjunction with partners like the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS) and the Illinois General Assembly, the IHSA draws input from top leaders in the sports medicine community. We solicit their expertise regularly and apply best practices in all events.

Risk minimization for high school student-athletes in all sports, including football, has been and will continue to be a top priority for the Association. We believe that since the IHSA began sanctioning football competition, the safety procedures and protocols in place for high school football have been on par with, or have exceeded, those that exist around the country, regardless of the level of football. We recognize that in the past decade new concerns have been raised about the game of football. The IHSA, the Illinois State Legislature, local school boards, and the high school coaches who are on the practice fields every day are all working together to address these concerns.

While this lawsuit alleges that it exists to help aid in that matter, simply put, high school football should not be subject to being dismantled or reassembled. Those who oversee safety measures on a day-to-day basis are the people best equipped to address these improvements, not those operating within the courts.

At its core, high school football is not college football, nor is it the NFL, and for the vast majority of these young players this is the highest level at which they will compete. The IHSA bears that in mind as it continues to bring safer standards of play to practice, games and off-season workouts.

A lawsuit’s attempt to lump all levels of football together has far-reaching implications, potential repercussions that threaten the future of all high school sports for the millions of students around the country who annually benefit from their participation experiences.

The Latest
Around 9:15 p.m., an 18-year-old man was walking in the 1400 block of East 57th Street when four males exited a white sedan and robbed him, Chicago police said.
The man was pulled from the water after a search and he was taken to St. Francis Hospital in Evanston where he was pronounced dead, police said.
Preliminary information indicates the person may have already been lying in the road before he was struck, officials said.
Just before 2 a.m., the man, 42, was sitting in a parked vehicle in the 9800 block of South Ellis Avenue when he was shot in the head, Chicago police said.
Too often, insurers deny coverage for genetic tests that have been established as a standard of modern health care and can have a significant impact on people’s lives.