John Litwicki of Joliet caught his best natural muskie (43 inches) on Sept. 18 while fishing a weed bar with a bucktail in the Hayward area of Wisconsin.

‘‘Then my buddy Jon Vyster had to one-up me,” Litwicki (in green coat above) emailed.

Vyster, who lives in Frankfort, caught a 44½-inch muskie on the same drift with a jerkbait.

That’s the right kind of fishing with friends.

FOTW, the celebration of big fish and good stories around Chicago fishing, runs Wednesdays on the Sun-Times’ outdoors page. Send nominations by Facebook (Dale Bowman), Twitter (@BowmanOutside) or email (straycasts@sbcglobal.net).