clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

As U.S. formally ends Afghanistan war, vets ask, ‘What have we ended up with at the end of it?’

Here’s what some U.S. veterans of the war say as the United States withdraws after nearly 20 years in Afghanistan.

Former Army Capt. Andrew Brennan, holding servicemen bracelets, lost one of his closest friends in the single deadliest day for U.S. troops during the now-ending war with Afghanistan.
Former Army Capt. Andrew Brennan, holding servicemen bracelets, lost one of his closest friends in the single deadliest day for U.S. troops during the now-ending war with Afghanistan.
Julio Cortez / AP

Images of the World Trade Center towers collapsing in New York were still fresh in the minds of the first American troops arriving in Afghanistan, as the United States launched an invasion targeting the Afghanistan-based al-Qaida leaders who plotted the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

More than 800,000 U.S. troops have served in the Central Asian country since then in a war that quickly expanded to confronting Afghanistan’s Taliban and to nation-building.

Now, the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, Gen. Scott Miller, has relinquished his command in Kabul, underscoring the winding down of America’s longest war.

One-third of the roughly four million troops who served in the post-9/11 wars in Afghanistan and Iraq served multiple tours, some in well-secured bases in times of comparative quiet, others facing improvised explosive devices on the roads, mortar and rocket attacks on their positions, and firefights. While the United States quickly succeeded in quelling the al-Qaida fighters behind the 9/11 attacks, Americans leave with the Taliban rapidly claiming fresh territory. Many Afghans fear the return of civil war,or strict Taliban rule with the Western troops’ departure.

Here’s what some U.S. veterans of the war with Afghanistan say as the United States withdraws after nearly 20 years:

ANDREW BRENNAN

ARMY VETERAN
U.S. Army veteran Andrew Brennan.
U.S. Army veteran Andrew Brennan.
Julio Cortez / AP

For Andrew Brennan, 36, of Baltimore, it’s the days the painful memories subside that bother him.

A former Army captain who flew combat missions, Brennan lost one of his closest friends, pilot Bryan Nichols, when his Chinook helicopter was shot down in 2011, killing 30 Americans, seven Afghan soldiers and one interpreter. It was the single deadliest day for U.S. troops during the war.

Brennan spent a week helping recover the bodies.

“As much as I hate admitting it, there are days that go by when I don’t think about Bryan, our crew and the team guys on the back of that aircraft,” Brennan says. “And if I don’t think about it and I was that close to it, what do most Americans think?”

Brennan honors those who gave their lives in the war. He has worn a “Killed in Action” bracelet in honor of Nichols for nearly a decade. And he has worked to get a memorial wall built for 9/11 veterans.

Still, he says he believes it was a senseless war.

“What have we ended up with at the end of it, other than trillions spent, 7,000-plus Americans dead and more than two broken generations of warriors?

“The only stakeholder group that learned anything through this entire period were politicians: They learned that the American population is so removed from their modern-day ‘legions’ that they can do anything with our nation’s all-volunteer military, and no one will pay attention or care enough to change it.”

JENNIFER BROFER

MARINE VETERAN
Marine Corps veteran Jennifer Brofer outside her apartment in Los Angeles.
Marine Corps veteran Jennifer Brofer outside her apartment in Los Angeles.
Damian Dovarganes / AP

Marine veteran Jennifer Brofer will never forget the loud, popping noise.

It was on a hot July afternoon in 2010 when her convoy rolled over an IED on a road in Helmand Province four months into her deployment to Afghanistan. Her heart froze as she and her fellow Marines stopped and realized what had happened. But what followed were only the sounds of daily life.

This was a lucky day.

“For some reason, it did not detonate,” the former staff sergeant says.

It was a defining moment to be that close to death, says Brofer, who was one of the comparatively few female Marines to serve in America’s longest war and now is a producer and actress in Los Angeles.

As a Marine Corps public affairs officer, Brofer’s job was to document the stories of troops.

“Those moments in Afghanistan really put everything into perspective for me. Because I really didn’t fully appreciate all of the luxuries that I had been afforded prior to my deployment,” she says — like hugs from loved ones, hot showers and driving down a road without fear of her vehicle exploding.

Brofer, 38, who works in the television and film industries in Hollywood, says she’s proud to have served “shoulder-to-shoulder with my male Marine counterparts” in a time of war.

Still, Brofer says she can’t say whether the war was worth it.

“War is ugly,” she says. “And sometimes it’s necessary. And it’s not like we can go back and change anything. We can only change how we respond in the future.

“When I was deployed, it was already considered then the longest war. And I think it’s about time that our men and women came home.”

ERAN HARRILL

NATIONAL GUARD
The names of servicemen who died when their Chinook helicopter was shot down in 2011 in Afghanistan are seen on a liquor bottle.
The names of servicemen who died when their Chinook helicopter was shot down in 2011 in Afghanistan are seen on a liquor bottle.
Julio Cortez / AP

After the United States launched a second war, in Iraq, in 2003, Oklahoma National Guard Sgt. Eran Harrill was one of hundreds of thousands of guard members called to duty as an all-volunteer U.S. military strained to fight two wars simultaneously.

Harrill fought in 2011 as part of a combat unit in Afghanistan’s Laghman Province, as the United States surged troops in hopes of crippling Afghanistan’s Taliban. A marketing director and business development executive in Oklahoma City, he patrolled alongside a mechanic, a K-9 police officer, students and other Oklahomans.

“The very first firefight we got in was certainly an ‘aha’ moment” for the citizen soldiers, says Harrill, 38, who had always wanted to serve in the military, even as some guard colleagues had seen it just as a way to bring in money for college. ”I think we did some good there, maybe helped some people and prevented some loss of life. Was it worth the loss of life we had? I don’t know. That’s for someone else to answer.”

Back home, Harrill leads Oklahoma City’s Black Chamber of Commerce. He’s developing a directory aimed at identifying which employers are most suitable for members of the military, like National Guard members.

That’s after seeing guard members struggle with bosses unhappy over time away for training and deployment, including managers who reached out to a deployed guard member in the field to threaten him with firing if he didn’t return.

“We have a bad habit in this country of putting little yellow ribbons, ‘support our troops,’ in the window,” Harrill says. “But we don’t really support our troops as to how it affects us when the rubber hits the road.”