A little COVID-19 legal sanity arrives on a great day for Gov. J.B. Pritzker
The governor had a banner day when it comes to enforcing new rules to protect the public from the virus.
Tuesday, August 11th, was probably the best day, professionally, that Gov. J.B. Pritzker has had in quite a while.
The Joint Committee on Administrative Rules has been a source of legislative frustration for the governor all year. He didn’t quite seem to grasp how best to work its process-dominated membership and he was handed a major defeat back in May when JCAR members in both parties turned thumbs down on a sweeping plan to impose fines and even jail time on violators of Pritzker’s COVID-19 executive orders.
In-depth political coverage, sports analysis, entertainment reviews and cultural commentary.
Pritzker’s general counsel Ann Spillane spent hours explaining to and negotiating with JCAR members the myriad details in the administration’s latest attempt at enforcing some of the governor’s executive orders on mask-wearing and gathering sizes. Spillane testified on behalf of the emergency rule that Tuesday, and she and her final product drew praise from members on both sides of the aisle, though some said they had “agreed to disagree.”
Enlisting organized labor and medical and public health leaders to help put public and private pressure on JCAR wasn’t a bad idea, either. And rather than relying on legislative leaders to put the arm on fellow Democrats, the governor himself got directly involved and called individual members of the committee.
The administration worked it hard and worked it well and it all paid off when it cleared the panel and took effect. The new administrative rule is far better than Pritzker’s attempt in May and also better than the draft released just a week earlier. That’s how things are supposed to work.
As the administration’s top lawyer, Spillane, who served former Attorney General Lisa Madigan as chief of staff, has also been heavily involved with the numerous court battles over Pritzker’s executive orders.
And the governor had a banner day at the Illinois Supreme Court that Tuesday as well. Pritzker had asked the day before that the state’s top court step in and put a stop to the charade in Clay County, where a judge had issued rulings on behalf of Rep. Darren Bailey (R-Xenia) that Will County Circuit Judge John Anderson recently wrote were “bereft of any meaningful legal analysis.”
Clay County Judge Michael McHaney was planning a hearing on Friday, Aug. 14, to decide whether to hold Pritzker in contempt for continuing to issue executive orders in defiance of McHaney’s rulings and perhaps throw the governor in jail. On Monday, the governor asked the Supreme Court to intervene on McHaney’s “unenforceable and nonappealable partial summary judgment order,” stay the contempt hearing and take up the case itself.
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court issued a stay on the contempt hearing and then, later in the day, decided not to take up the case. The state’s high court instead acted on its own to consolidate Bailey’s case with others that it had already shifted to Sangamon County at the governor’s behest. The court also ordered that another Clay County case filed by Bailey’s attorney over the administration’s school reopening guidance (including a face mask mandate) be consolidated with similar cases in Sangamon County.
The Supreme Court justices obviously had seen enough of Clay County’s show trials and finally stepped in to stop a county judge from attempting to dictate to the state. The media-friendly legal maneuverings will likely continue, but at least they’ll now happen on a level judicial playing field (unless another avenue is found).
There were some who believed Ann Spillane should’ve cashed out in the private sector after Lisa Madigan retired. Spillane wanted to continue her public service career, however, and Pritzker is darned lucky to have her, especially during this unforeseen pandemic.
Meanwhile, the Republican leadership here has managed to put themselves on the side of outliers like Rep. Bailey. House Republican Leader Jim Durkin, for one, publicly opposed Pritzker’s emergency rule on masks, though national and regional public opinion polls have revealed strong support for requiring face-coverings.
And that public support likely will continue because mask mandates appear to be working. Lincoln, Nebraska, has dramatically lowered its daily case count and positivity rate after imposing a mask mandate just a few weeks ago. It worked so well that Omaha’s city council unanimously approved a similar mandate last Tuesday night over opposition from the state’s governor.
Some business groups opposed Pritzker’s mask rule, and the cash-strapped House Republicans need every bit of help they can get in a year that’s not looking good for their party here. So I suppose it was a decent short-term decision. But that’s going to be a difficult position to defend in some of their suburban battlegrounds.
Rich Miller also publishes Capitol Fax, a daily political newsletter, and CapitolFax.com.
Send letters to email@example.com.