Historic Pilgrim Baptist Church damaged by windstorm

The historic building’s limestone shell was going to be renovated and expanded to become home to the National Museum of Gospel Music. But the damage sustained Monday could delay that project.

SHARE Historic Pilgrim Baptist Church damaged by windstorm
Storm damage at Pilgrim Baptist Church, 3301 S. Indiana Ave. in Bronzeville, shown on Tuesday, Aug. 11, 2020.

The south wall of Pilgrim Baptist Church, 3301 S. Indiana Ave. in Bronzeville, collapsed in Monday’s storms. Already gutted by a 2006 fire, the historic site is the planned location for a National Museum of Gospel Music — a plan likely delayed by the storm damaged.

Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times

It didn’t take long for Cynthia Jones to find out how badly Pilgrim Baptist Church had been damaged when winds of nearly 100 mph tore through the city Monday afternoon.

By 4:15 p.m., Jones, chair of the church’s board of trustees, had gotten calls from plenty of neighbors.

“Any time you have any kind of damage, you’re concerned,” Jones said Tuesday. “I have faith in God it’s for a reason.”

Tuesday afternoon, heaps of bricks rested in front of what used to be the south wall of the church, at 3301 S. Indiana Ave. in Douglas.

High winds that swept through the Chicago area Monday left a tragic mark at the vacant limestone shell of Pilgrim Baptist Church.

High winds that swept through the Chicago area Monday left a tragic mark at the vacant limestone shell of Pilgrim Baptist Church.

Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times

Now, only two walls remain intact — the north and west walls, made of limestone and braced by metal beams.

The building has been a shell since January 2006, when it was gutted by fire.

Since 2017, the church has been fundraising for a plan to build the National Museum of Gospel Music. The project was to be completed this fall but already had been delayed to 2022, Jones said.

A firefighter walks in front of the Pilgrim Baptist Church as it goes up in flames in Chicago, Friday, Jan. 6, 2006. Fire destroyed the landmark 1890 church on Chicago’s South Side that played a major role in the development of gospel music in the 1930s.

Pilgrim Baptist Church was gutted by fire on Jan. 6, 2006.

Associated Press

Instead of halting plans for the museum, Don Jackson — founder and CEO of Chicago-based Central City Productions and the “visionary” behind the museum project — called the collapse a “godsend.”

“This forces the urgency,” Jackson said. “This has been a blessing for the project that says that we need to get started,” adding that he still thinks the museum can open in September 2022.

The state has allocated $2.1 million to the museum, but Jackson said the church has yet to receive the money. He expects the state and city each will contribute about $10 million total to the project, now estimated to cost $48 million, Jackson said. Monday’s destruction could expedite state and city action, he said.

A chunk of the south wall lays atop a pile of bricks Tuesday, Aug. 11, 2020, after the wall at Pilgrim Baptist Church collapsed Monday, Aug. 10, 2020 in the wind storm.

A chunk of the south wall at Pilgrim Baptist Church, which was damaged in Monday’s windstorm.

Clare Proctor/Sun-Times

Others worry the wall’s collapse could upend the project.

Ward Miller, executive director of Preservation Chicago, a nonprofit advocacy organization, said though he “loves the idea of a gospel museum,” operating and maintaining a museum is expensive. Still, he would welcome “anything” to preserve the space, such as an open-air concert venue, a community center or a fieldhouse.

“It’s still an important component to save,” Miller said. “It has a lot of significance to the nation and to the world, culturally in music and, of course, architecturally.”

Bracing supports the remaining limestone walls of the shell of Pilgrim Baptist Church, 3301 S. Indiana Ave.

Bracing supports the remaining limestone walls of the shell of Pilgrim Baptist Church, 3301 S. Indiana Ave.

Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times

Built in 1890 and designed by famous architects Dankmar Adler and Louis Sullivan, the building originally operated as a synagogue before the church purchased the property in 1922. Thomas A. Dorsey, considered the “father of gospel music” was a choir director at the church, which many consider to be the music style’s birthplace.

Since the fire, the church congregation, community groups and gospel performers have proposed myriad plans to preserve the building’s history, eventually landing on the National Museum of Gospel Music in 2017.

Cynthia Jones, chair of the Pilgrim Baptist Church board of trustees, has been a member of the church since she was seven, taken on Aug. 11, 2020. Now in her 70s, Jones said the wall’s collapse Monday is a “hiccup” in comparison to the “day and night of devastation” in the 2006 fire.

Cynthia Jones, chair of the Pilgrim Baptist Church board of trustees, has been a member of the church since she was seven. Now in her 70s, Jones said the wall’s collapse Monday is a “hiccup” in comparison to the “day and night of devastation” in the 2006 fire.

Clare Proctor/Sun-Times

Jones, who’s in her 70s, said she’s attended the church since she was baptized there at age 7. The church now meets across the street at 3300 S. Indiana Ave. Monday’s destruction is a “hiccup” compared to the “day and night of devastation” of the 2006 fire.

Jones is “confident” there will be a museum, she said — it’s only a matter of time. She anticipates Monday’s damage could delay the project a year.

“We’re very positive that’s going to come to fruition,” she said. “It should be here. Where else would it be besides Chicago?”

Rendering of the proposed National Museum of Gospel Music

Rendering of the proposed National Museum of Gospel Music.

Provided by Wight & Company

The north and west walls of Pilgrim Baptist Church, made of the original limestone, are still standing, Tuesday, Aug. 11, 2020.

The north and west walls of Pilgrim Baptist Church, made of the original limestone, still stand.

Clare Proctor/Sun-Times

The Latest
After allowing hits to five of the first nine hitters he faced Friday, Sampson switched to his off-speed pitches and retired 12 of the next 14.
Christopher Morel’s versatility is conjuring memories of Ben Zobrist, and the Cubs are putting him to good use.
Hendriks said he’ll come off the injured list Monday, when the Sox open a stretch of games against AL Central teams. “We need to fall in love with the game again,” he said.
Court watchers say the high court reaches decisions based on politics, not constitutional law. Even lawyers who watch the court carefully say you don’t have to be steeped in constitutional law these days to predict how the court will rule.
Biden’s honors list includes both living and deceased honorees from the worlds of Hollywood, sports, politics, the military, academia, and civil rights and social justice advocacy.