Dental hygienists in Illinois face a roadblock from dentists lobby as they’ve pushed to do more
The failure of legislation to allow hygienists wider duties illustrates the power of the Illinois State Dental Society. Illinois trails many states in allowing dental hygienists unsupervised contact with patients.
This year, the Illinois Legislature was considering measures to expand oral health treatment in a state where millions live in dental care deserts.
But when the Illinois State Dental Society met virtually with key lawmakers for its annual lobbying day last spring, the proposals to allow dental hygienists to clean the teeth of certain underprivileged patients without a dentist seemed doomed.
State Sen. Dave Syverson, R-Rockford, the Senate Republican leader, warned against the bills even if they sounded minor.
“It’s just getting the camel’s nose under the tent,” Syverson said in an audio recording of the meeting obtained by KHN. “We’ll have, before long, hygienists doing the work that, if they wanted to do, they should have gone to dental school for.”
The senator also said he missed “the reception and the dinners that you guys host” and the “nice softball questions that I usually get” from the dental society’s past president, who happens to be his first cousin.
The bills never made it out of committee.
The situation in Illinois is indicative of the types of legislative dynamics that play out when lower-level healthcare providers such as dental hygienists, nurse practitioners and optometrists try to gain greater autonomy and access to patients. And the fate of the Illinois legislation illustrates the power that lobbying groups such as the Illinois dental society have in shaping policies on where health professionals can practice and who keeps the profits.
“There’s always a struggle,” said Margaret Langelier, a researcher for the Center for Health Workforce Studies at the University of Albany in New York. “We have orthopedists fighting podiatrists over who can take care of the ankle. We have psychiatrists fighting with clinical psychologists about who can prescribe and what they can prescribe. We have nurses fighting pharmacists over injections and vaccinations. It’s the turf battles.”
In 2015, the Illinois Dental Practice Act was revised to let hygienists treat low-income patients on Medicaid or without insurance in public health settings — such as schools, safety-net clinics and programs for mothers and children — without a dentist examining them or being on site. Besides doing cleanings, hygienists also can take X-rays, place sealants and apply fluoride.
The state dental society, in a memo to members, wrote that the fact it took years for hygienists to develop their public health training program shows “they have no real interest in providing access to care to needy patients.”
Illinois trails many states in allowing dental hygienists unsupervised contact with patients. In Colorado, on the extreme end, hygienists can own practices.
“It’s just the nature of the beast politically in Illinois,” said Margaret Vaughn, executive director of the Illinois Rural Health Association. “The dental lobby isn’t as strong in those other states. The Illinois State Dental Society is much more powerful, and they’re much more organized than the hygienists are politically.”
From 2015 to 2019, the dental society spent more than $55,000 on lobbying, for its annual gathering and for meals for lawmakers, typically hosted at a swanky Italian spot near the state Capitol in Springfield, according to its financial disclosure statements. In the same period, the Illinois Dental Hygienists Association reported spending nothing in its lobbying reports. Neither group has listed any expenditures since the beginning of 2020.
The dental society has two exclusive lobbyists and four lobbying firms on contract, state records show. The hygienist group doesn’t employ its own lobbyist and contracts with one lobbying firm.
The dental society gives generously to both Republicans and Democrats. Its political action committee had nearly $742,000 in cash on hand as of June 30, according to Reform for Illinois’ Sunshine Database. While the PAC has given $4,050 since 2014 to support the campaigns of state Sen. Melinda Bush, D-Grayslake, who sponsored the nursing home bill, it has contributed more than $123,000 since 1999 to the campaigns of Syverson, the senator who spoke at the conference, with bigger annual gifts than it’s given Bush.
“I receive contributions from many groups on both sides of issues,” Syverson said. “They are not contributing to influence my vote on a particular bill. In fact, if a PAC sent a check while we were negotiating or voting on an issue they are involved with, I would not accept it.”
The hygienists’ PAC gave $1,100 to the campaign committee of Bush, according to the database, and nothing to Syverson.
Bush did not respond to requests for comment.
“The bottom line is: If you don’t have a healthy mouth, you don’t have a healthy body,” said Ann Lynch, director of advocacy and education for the American Dental Hygienists Association. “It only makes sense that we would remove any barriers that do not allow a licensed healthcare provider to practice at the top of their scope.”
Dave Marsh, a lobbyist for the state dental society, said it would be dangerous for hygienists to treat nursing home residents, who often are elderly and sick.
“I just don’t feel anybody with a two-year associate’s degree is medically qualified to correct your health,” Marsh said. “They’re trained to clean teeth. They take a sharp little instrument and scrape your teeth. That’s what they do. That’s all they do.”
He said the problem is not a shortage of dental professionals but a lack of dentists who can afford to accept Medicaid patients — and “nobody wants to raise taxes to actually be able to reimburse” dentists at higher rates.
Marsh also pointed to the scarcity of research on the benefits of dental hygienists having more professional freedom.
Langelier said little academic literature exists about this in part because of inadequate data collection on oral health. But in 2016, a study she co-authored that was published in the journal Health Affairs found that, as dental hygienists gained more autonomy, fewer people had teeth removed because of decay or disease. And she said Medicaid data show more children had dental visits as hygienists expanded their practice.
“I don’t want this to be acrimonious,” said Laura Scully, chair of the access-to-care committee of the state hygienists association. “I would like it to be more of a collaboration, because truly that’s what this is about: getting together so we can help more people.”
Karen Webster, a dental hygienist for the Tri City Health Partnership, a free clinic in St. Charles, said that, in the past, she could only briefly screen patients before scheduling them with one of the center’s volunteer dentists, often months out.
“Imagine if you had a toothache, and the doctor couldn’t see you that day,” Webster said, noting that her patients have low incomes. “They can’t afford the services. They wait till something hurts.”
But since becoming a public health dental hygienist, Webster said she now does immediate cleanings, takes X-rays that she sends to teledentists for exams and applies a solution called silver diamine fluoride that can halt tooth decay.
“The whole thing, start to finish, it’s just a lot more efficient,” she said.
KHN (Kaiser Health News) is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism on health issues.