clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Chicago’s top cop blames the courts — again — after one of the most violent Fourth of July weekends in years

But the police superintendent was immediately attacked by Cook County’s state’s attorney, chief judge and public defender, who all said Brown’s criticism was simplistic and not based on reality.

Chicago Police Supt. David Brown speaks at a news conference following a violent Fourth of July weekend in the city.
Brian Rich/Sun-Times

Chicago’s top cop found himself under fire from the chief judge and prosecutor of Cook County Tuesday after he once again blamed them for the city’s rising gun violence, including a holiday weekend that saw over 100 people shot.

Police Supt. David Brown complained at a news conference that Cook County courts release too many violent criminals, with judges setting low bonds and relying too much on electronic monitoring.

“Chicago police officers are doing their job by arresting people and charging them with murder,” Brown insisted. “That’s doing our part. And what’s happening in the courts, it’s creating this unsafe environment for all of us.”

But Timothy Evans, chief judge of Cook County Circuit Court, dismissed Brown’s criticism as simplistic. “Speculation based on isolated cases is not the same as reality based on a complete picture,” he said in a statement.

State’s Attorney Kim Foxx turned Brown’s criticism against him, saying police need to make more arrests for violent crimes.

“It starts with apprehending those who pull the trigger,” she said in a statement. “Police must make an arrest before a case reaches the courthouse door.”

Amid the heated exchange of words, an alderman once again proposed sending in the National Guard, an idea Mayor Lori Lightfoot described as grandstanding. “I don’t think I need to say anything more about that,” she said.

The police department said it would have no other comment about the weekend violence beyond what the superintendent said at the news conference.

Both Brown and Lightfoot have repeatedly questioned the decisions of prosecutors and judges as this year’s violence continues to outpace 2020, the most violent year in the city since the mid-1990s.

In making his case yet again, Brown pointed to more than 90 people charged with murder who were later released back into their communities on electronic monitoring.

“If the cops’ productivity was down and not unprecedentedly high, I would be arguing we need to do more as police officers. That’s not the case here,” Brown said, noting officers recovered 244 illegal guns over the holiday weekend, resulting in 86 arrests.

Brown did not say if police had made any arrests in any of the weekend shootings, including attacks that wounded at least 13 children 15 years of age and younger.

This holiday was the most violent Fourth of July weekend since 2017, when at least 101 people were shot, 14 fatally. However, the holiday was on a Tuesday that year, so the tally covered four full days; this year’s tally covered three days.

Many of the shootings were in the Calumet and South Chicago police districts on the South Side, in neighborhoods that have seen more violence this year than last, according to Sun-Times data.

Brown was quick to point out violent crime in other major cities has increased dramatically more than Chicago, both last year and this year. “It’s a violent crime wave that’s happening in this country,” he said.

So far in 2021, murders are up nearly 18% nationally, according to statistics compiled by crime analyst Jeff Asher, while Chicago has seen an increase of nearly 4% from the same period last year.

However, murders last year in Chicago jumped by more than 50%, much higher than the national increase of 30%.

The nearly 800 killings in Chicago in 2020 still fell short of the city’s annual tolls during much of the 1980s and 1990s, though it was the highest number of slayings in 20 years.

“No one would do the job that Chicago police officers do right now. No one would wade into large crowds and risk being shot,” Brown said. “No one would go down these dark alleys that officers go down.”

Two officers — a commander and a sergeant — were wounded on the West Side early Sunday while dispersing a crowd. One was hit in the foot, the other grazed in the thigh.

Brown said blaming the courts wasn’t “finger pointing,” but an attempt to spur further debate. “I think people should hear this,” he said. “This is a worthwhile debate here and in all places around the country.”

But Evans insisted “bail reform has not led to an increase in crime. Looking at individual tragic cases in isolation may contribute to the speculation that releasing individuals before trial rather than incarcerating them — whether by placing them on electronic monitoring or other forms of supervision — means an increase in crime.”

There were 100 murder defendants on electronic monitoring as of Tuesday, out of 3,500 on such restraints, according to the sheriff’s office. Of the entire group, 72% were facing charges for violent crimes.

In July 2017, before new policies limiting limit pre-trial jail time for all but the most dangerous defendants, there were 2,200 on electronic monitoring, and 32% faced charges related to violent crime, the office said.

Foxx, after taking a swipe at the low number of arrests by Brown’s department, argued “finger-pointing instead of talking honestly about the violence plaguing our city doesn’t help bring solutions that make our communities safer.

“The violence we are experiencing is not the result of a slowed down court system; it is a larger and more complex issue (both locally and nationally), that requires all of the criminal justice stakeholders to work together rather than engaging in deflection and blame-shifting,” she said.

Cook County Public Defender Sharone Mitchell said Brown’s and Lightfoot’s message might be politically expedient, but it detracts from efforts to suppress crime through community outreach.

Mitchell watched Brown’s press conference online, and disagreed with the superintendent’s assessment that the large number of people charged with murder on electronic monitoring devices are “driving the violence.”

“If you are charged with something as serious as murder, you probably have posted a very high cash bond and are still subject to all sorts of restrictions. You’re being monitored on GPS, so we know exactly where you are. You have curfews. You have to check in with the court,” said Mitchell, whose office represents roughly 90% of all criminal defendants in Cook County.

“This idea that if the courts would just ‘do their job’ and we would all be safer flies in the face of numerous studies,” Mitchell said. “Crime is up in cities all over the U.S. right now, and that covers cities with conservative bond policies and bond reform.

“I feel for the superintendent. He has a very difficult job,” he added. “But we have to get away from asking what the superintendent is going to do on a Thursday to stop violence over the weekend.”

Meanwhile, Ald. Anthony Beale (9th) called for the deployment of the Illinois National Guard “immediately to get a handle on this city.”

He said the Guard wouldn’t patrol neighborhoods and streets, but instead would “secure the perimeter” around downtown, freeing more police officers to be sent to communities.

Asked about critics who say they don’t want their neighborhoods turned into armed camps, Beale responded: “I get that, but my question to them is, what’s your plan? I’ll be more than willing to listen to anybody who has a plan going forward. But just complaining and not having a plan doesn’t resonate with me.”