Teen’s mother helped identify him as shooter in gang-related slaying in Austin: prosecutors

Joshua Scarver, 18, was ordered held without bail Sunday in last month’s fatal shooting. Prosecutors said his mother acknowledged in a videotaped statement that she personally saw her son open fire during the attack.

SHARE Teen’s mother helped identify him as shooter in gang-related slaying in Austin: prosecutors
A 19-year-old was charged in connection to a May 29, 2022 shooting in River North.

An 18-year-old man was ordered held without bail Sunday after allegedly killing a member of a rival gang faction.

Adobe Stock Photo

A teenager’s mother helped identify him as the shooter in a fatal gang-related attack last month in Austin, prosecutors said during his initial court hearing Sunday.

Joshua Scarver, 18, of Austin, was charged with first-degree murder in the Sept. 16 slaying of 20-year-old Charles Starks, according to authorities.


Joshua Scarver

Chicago police

During Scarver’s bond hearing Sunday, prosecutors told Judge Susana Ortiz his mother acknowledged in a videotaped statement that she personally saw her son fire multiple gunshots during the attack in the 600 block of North Central Avenue. Scarver, who was just 17 at the time, was ultimately held without bail. If convicted, he faces a possible life sentence.

Prosecutors said the shooting followed “several hostile incidents” between rival gang factions, including an incident a week earlier during which Scarver forcibly stole money and cannabis from Starks and an individual who witnessed the fatal shooting. Friends of Starks later retaliated and fought with Scarver, prosecutors said.

The conflict came to a head about 6:45 p.m. Sept. 16, when Starks and the witness were biking through an alley in the 600 block of North Central Avenue and ran into Scarver, prosecutors said. Scarver then punched Starks, walked to an SUV and started firing off a handgun.

Starks was struck three times as he and the other individual attempted to ride off, prosecutors said. The other apparent target ultimately fled to a youth center, called 911 and gave police the location of the attack.

Starks was found unresponsive in the alley and later pronounced dead at a hospital, prosecutors said. Twenty-five shell casings were found strewn throughout the alley.

A witness reported hearing as many as 10 gunshots from inside his home, prosecutors said. When the witness stepped outside, he heard roughly 10 more shots and saw a black male holding a handgun and entering the passenger side of an SUV on a nearby parking slab that took off.

Investigators learned an SUV that parks in that spot belongs to Scarver’s mother, prosecutors said. While she’s not the registered owner, prosecutors noted police have stopped her in the vehicle.

After conducting surveillance on the SUV, police took Scarver and his mother into custody on Friday, prosecutors said. Investigators then determined the mother was a witness in the case — not a possible offender.

In a videotaped interview, she told investigators she saw her son emerge from the SUV with a handgun during the fight with Starks, prosecutors said. She then saw her son shoot “repeatedly” at Starks before returning to the SUV, where she said he started shooting again. For his part, Scarver gave several different accounts before admitting “he was present in the alley and shot at the victim.”

Prosecutors noted Carver hadn’t previously been arrested as an adult, though he has a juvenile background. That includes an aggravated robbery arrest in 2017 that resulted in a sentence of two years probation, prosecutors said.

Scarver’s public defender described him as a high school student who’s active in his church community and who recently started working as a package handler.

Citing the wealth of evidence, including his mother’s statement, Ortiz ordered Scarver held without bail. “There’d be no better person to be familiar with Mr. Scarver’s identify than his mother,” Ortiz noted.

Though Ortiz barred Scarver from having any contact with witnesses, she said that order could be readdressed if he needs to speak to his mother.

Scarver’s next court date was set for Tuesday.

The Latest
“You learn some of the nuances or quirks about a person’s personality when you’re traveling with them, for certain,” one expert says.
The first daily edition was a reminder to readers that, while they were reading a new paper, they could trust the reporting. That has never changed.
The wrongful death lawsuit was filed by the father of a man shot and killed by Kyle Rittenhouse during a protest in 2020.
The online auction will take place from Feb. 6-10 and also includes Rolex watches and an 1833 Carson City Morgan silver dollar.
Eva Bratcher, 69, was taken into custody shortly after police on a well-being check found the body of 96-year-old Regina Michalski around 4:35 p.m. Monday in the 5500 block of West Melrose Street.