Fixing terms for up to 5,000 teachers could avert possible strike

SHARE Fixing terms for up to 5,000 teachers could avert possible strike
strike_040216_39_60380579.jpg

Chicago Teachers Union rally and march in downtown Chicago April 1, 2016. File Photo by Brian Jackson/For the Sun-Times

Finding a way to hold harmless up to 5,000 teachers who have maxed out on their pay raises for education and seniority may be the key to averting Chicago’s second teachers strike in fouryears.

Daysafter the Chicago Teachers Union’s 40-person bargaining unit pushed for an October deadline, sources with knowledge of the negotiationsoutlined a possible pathway toward an agreement.

The $5.4 billion budget approved this week by Mayor Rahm Emanuel’s handpicked Board of Education includes a $250 million property tax increase for teacher pensions and assumes $31 million in labor concessions reached partlyby phasing out a 7 percent pension payment awarded to teachers years ago in lieu of a pay raise.

Sources close to the negotiations described eliminating that “pension pickup” as a non-negotiable “structural reform.”

But instead of phasing out the 7 percent CPS contribution over a two-year period, sources said it’s possible teachers could be asked to assume the burden over a three-year period.

Even moreimportant are the 4,000 to 5,000 teachers who have been on the job for 14 years or more and are in the highest of the “steps” for experience. Unlike lower steps that see an increase forexperience every year,steps14 and 15 require upward offive years’ service each before maxing out on step 16 in their 25th year.

That pool of veteran teachers would still come out ahead at the end of the four-year contract because of annual pay raises that would leave the average teacher with 6 percent more, even afterphasing out the pension pickup.

Buttheveteranteachersin the top three stepswouldcome upshort in thesecondandthird years of the agreement so far.

Holding themharmless would cost roughly $8 million. Finding the money to do just that could hold the key to an agreement, and it’s likely to be a focal point for ongoingnegotiations.

CTUattorney Robert Blochagreed that “not everybody gets a step” and that the union takes issue with treating those steps as annual increases butrather “assomething reflectingyour longevityand learning your craft.”

“If thecontract is valued as steps as being part of thecompensation, those teachers are left out,” he said. “Thestepshould not be counted, they should look at across the board raises. That’s an area of disagreement between us.”

Bloch continued, “The union’s position is no cuts. So they are not agreeable that any teacher takes home less pay.Theschool board’s books should not be balanced by taking money out of the paychecksof teachers,” nearly allof whom live in the city andare paying higher property taxes imposed by City Council and the Board of Ed.

“The deal that we reached on Jan. 29 is a fair foundation for a final agreement, and we are open and willing to listen to any ideas that the CTU leadership presents to make the framework work better for both parties,” district spokeswoman Emily Bittner said. “CPS’ continued objective is to give teachers a raise that works within our budget constraints, especially since we just passed a tight budget that included significant tax hikes on Chicago homeowners, Central Office staffing reductions and revenue from Springfield.”

She alsohighlighted severalquality-of-life elements, reachedin last winter’sagreement, that the CTU has long requested, such as reducedpaperwork, grading autonomy, evaluation changes and more community schools.

Several sourcessaid Emanuel, schools CEO Forrest Claypool and the teachers union still agreeto “go together to Springfield” to push for a graduated state income tax that could provide a windfall for CPS.

As it is, the CPS budget is precariously balanced on the assumption of $215 million in pension help from Springfield that’s contingent on a solution to the state’s pension crisis. That’s a huge “if” considering the marathon budget stalemate between Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner and Democratic legislative leaders who control the Illinois General Assembly.

Earlier this year, a much-anticipated report from an independent fact-finder tasked with sorting out the teacher contract dispute was “virtuallyunchanged” from an offer the union shot down in February.

That put CTU President Karen Lewis in a box to try to re-sell the deal she was unable to sell before to her union’s more radical elements, or considerleading her members out on strike for the second time in four years.

The proposal that Lewis had labeled a “serious offer” included net raises over four years; the phasing out over two years of a 7 percent pension contribution CPS has been making on members’ behalf; and a return to raises for continuing education and experience as soon as the nextschool year.

None of those main economic points changed in the findings made by independent arbitrator Steven Bierig. Neither did the improvedteaching conditionsoffered in January. Thoseinclude giving teachers more power over grading, increasing the number of community schools and eliminating burdensome paperwork — all improvements the CTU has demanded.

The union’s “Big Bargaining Team”unanimously rejected the offer, saying CPS needed new revenue or it was offeringraises while requiring a set number ofteachers to retire. It also didn’t count onCPS to be abletoenforce a cap on charters while a state boardstill haspower to overturn the district’s decisions.

Even if a way can be found to hold harmless the 5,000 most senior teachers, sources said Lewis will have to play a more active role in “selling” the new contract. It won’t be enough to simply call the deal a “serious offer” and let the chips fall where they may.

Ald. Pat O’Connor (40th), the former longtime chairman of the City Council’s Education Committee now serving as Emanuel’s floor leader, was somewhat pessimistic when asked whether he believes Chicago can avoid a bitter repeat of the 2012 teachers strike.

“The teachers seem to be drawing a real line in the sand. If they stick to the idea that they’re not gonna pay one more dime toward their pensions and they want a salary increase, it’s almost inevitable” that there will be a strike, O’Connor said Thursday.

“If those are the requirements not to strike, I don’t think we can meet those requirements. There’s no money,” he said. “The budget itself is balanced on the good will of Springfield. It’s a very precarious thing to begin with. The additional money we acquired from Springfield was predicated on us getting help from the other quarters [including teachers]. And it’s not enough to accomplish the goals that teachers have set out. But if it’s a bargaining, hopefully we’ll get to a place where we can all agree.”

The Latest
Pet owners beware; the flea population in the Chicago area will be higher this summer, according to the Companion Animal Parasite Council.
The Cubs radio analyst, a Southwest Side son, spent a day reliving his past — and the emotions came flooding back.
At least nine people died nationwide and an estimated 11,500 were injured last year in accidents involving fireworks, according to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission.
Local 150 of the International Union of Operating Engineers has been off the job since June 7 and no talks are scheduled.
A team spokesperson said the franchise stuck with White, who is now the voice of LIV Golf, because they felt it wasn’t appropriate to judge where he chose to work outside the club.