Elizabeth Clark asked a good question, and dozens of readers responded well.
‘‘It’s obvious that the ‘lure’ of ice fishing or fishing in this weather is very strong,’’ she emailed. ‘‘Can you or some of your contributors tell us mere mortals/the uninitiated what it is that draws them to go out in these extreme conditions?’’
‘‘Part of the lure is being, in many people’s eyes, the crazy guy that braves the elements, regardless of cold and wind,’’ Jason Langford posted. ‘‘Also . . . there is a serenity that you find patiently sitting in a small enclosure, cut off from the world except for a small hole into the unknown below.’’
‘‘Frozen lakes are very calming, shockingly quiet most times,’’ Kyle Lamm tweeted. ‘‘Staring at a Vexilar and jigging puts me in a trance sometimes.’’
‘‘Ice fishing with a Vexilar is addictive,’’ Ryan Whitacre posted. ‘‘I’ve had dreams about marks coming off the bottom.’’
Vexilars are flashers that show fish (marks).
Ben Dickinson, Indiana’s Lake Michigan fisheries biologist, weighed in with this: ‘‘Ice fishing levels the playing field. Access becomes easier. You don’t need a boat or a boat launch, even. Staying vertical over fish or structure is easier, and fine-tuning presentations is a lot of fun. In many ways, it can be more interactive than open-water fishing, especially if you have a flasher and can basically see fish reactions to your presentation in real time.’’
Michael Walsh and others emphasized the egalitarian nature of ice fishing.
‘‘Enables us to get out on lakes that are not accessible without a boat,’’ he tweeted.
‘‘It’s pretty low-maintenance,’’ Patrick Patel tweeted. ‘‘All my gear fits in a sled. Open-water gear is strewn all over [the] basement.’’
Kevin Irons, Illinois’ aquatic nuisance species program manager, noted: ‘‘With the auger as the exception, this CAN be an extremely affordable and efficient outing. A handful of small hooks, a small cork and some line, and you are off to the races! Sometimes a friendly fisher will help with the hole, too!’’
And, as John Heneghan noted, ‘‘I think fish in winter have a firmer meat.’’
The challenge is firmer, too.
‘‘I think finding and understanding winter fish is tougher,’’ Chad Rauch posted. ‘‘Throw in that you’re essentially fishing two to three 5- to 8-inch holes in a body of water, as opposed to casting where you want, so success is more rewarding.’’
Memories build from the challenge.
‘‘I was about 8 years old at my uncle’s in northern Minnesota with family,’’ Heather Hollaar posted. ‘‘About four of us were in his ice shack, and it was so much fun. When you’re in snow gear and inside a medium-size shed on the lake, it’s not really cold. Something relaxing about being out there.’’
‘‘The community of ice fishing brings a lot of guys together that would otherwise not interact on a shoreline of an open-water lake,’’ Tyler Peterson posted. ‘‘Maybe it’s the cold or the fact that everyone can ‘cast’ to those spots that only boat fishermen can access in the summer. But there is a comradeship between ice fishermen that does not exist in the open-water world.’’
‘‘Your creative juices get flowing, and [there is] the excitement of never knowing the size [of the fish] until it pokes through the hole,’’ Jim ‘‘The Crappie Professor’’ Kopjo posted. ‘‘We actually dial in open-water spots by getting right on top of cover and structure with our underwater cameras.’’
Carly Mullady Cowan wraps it up with this: ‘‘I can say there’s something special about walking on water! It’s so calm and so deeply serene. There’s no way to avoid feeling deeply in touch with nature — the bundling up, the thermoses of hot coffee/chocolate/cider, cozying up in a shanty. It is a truly unique experience where you feel completely separate from the hustling and bustling of regular life.’’