As violent crime soars in Chicago, ‘safety gap’ among neighborhoods widens

West Garfield Park, the city’s most dangerous community area, has seen a rate of shootings nearly 20 times higher than downtown, a Sun-Times analysis finds. The gap is even higher with six other police districts on the North Side.

SHARE As violent crime soars in Chicago, ‘safety gap’ among neighborhoods widens

Chicago police work the scene where a 4-year-old girl and a 19-year-old man were wounded in a shooting in West Garfield Park in August.

Tyler LaRiviere/Sun-Times

Don’t feel safe downtown? Try heading to West Garfield Park. 

The 16 police beats that cover most of the greater downtown area have seen a total of 77 shootings so far this year, which is triple the number of shootings there compared to 2019, a Sun-Times analysis has found.

That total, however, isn’t that much greater than the 62 shootings in a single, eight-by-five block section of West Garfield Park that comprises the city’s single most-violent beat.

West Garfield Park, the city’s most dangerous community area, has experienced a per capita rate of shootings nearly 20 times higher than downtown, according to the Sun-Times analysis of city data.

The gap is even higher with six other police districts that make up much of the North Side.

CST: Senior Tax Freeze Map

Crime has surged across the city in 2020 and this year, but the wave has been hardest on neighborhoods far from the city center that have long experienced violence at terrifyingly elevated rates. And the gap in safety between the city’s mostly white, affluent neighborhoods and largely poor, Black and Latino areas has never been greater.

So far this year, the murder rate in the seven most dangerous police districts rose to a three-decade high of nearly 100 homicides per 100,000 residents — 30 times higher than the rate in the safest seven districts, where the rate fell to fewer than four per 100,000, according to an analysis by the University of Chicago Crime Lab.

“People say it’s a tale of two cities: Downtown is like Manhattan, and the South and West sides have homicide rates comparable to violent South American countries,” said Kimberly Smith, director of programs for the crime lab. 

Residents of high-crime neighborhoods increasingly have moved out of the city, though the city saw a slight increase in population in the latest 2020 census, with big increases in people living downtown.

“The loss of life is not a good thing obviously, and the fact that it’s concentrated in a few areas is not good,” Smith said. “If we believe that homicides are driving people out of the city, homicides aren’t good if they happen downtown or in West Garfield Park.”

Even during the high-crime years of the 1990s, the gap in the homicide rate for Chicago’s seven safest police districts was far smaller — roughly seven times lower than the seven least safe districts.

Killings in all districts mostly declined over the next decade, then began climbing in the least-safe districts in early 2004 as rates continued to decline elsewhere.

Murder rates jumped in the least safe districts in 2016, from 45 to 81 per 100,000, and have stayed high.


Chicago police keep watch outside bars near East Hubbard and North State streets on the Near North Side, early Saturday, Oct. 2, 2021.

Ashlee Rezin/Sun-Times

Despite the staffing shortages that have led to backups in police response to emergencies across the city, Rena Cunningham, who lives in Englewood, was surprised to see the resources available for downtown late on a recent Friday night. 

Visiting downtown from the South Side with friends, Cunningham looked out at a half dozen squad cars that were blocking West Hubbard Street between State Street and Dearborn Street. Cunningham has seen plenty of squad cars in his South Side neighborhood, where there have been more than 300 shootings his year, more than 40 of them fatal.

The police were out in force for a different reason: to keep watch as tow trucks hauled away cars parked on Hubbard for violating the midnight-to-5 a.m. parking ban on the block. The parking enforcement was at the request of business owners in response to the mugging of two men who were badly beaten and robbed outside a convenience store around the corner.

“I have never seen this many cars in my neighborhood unless somebody was shot,” Cunningham said.

Data analysis: Andy Boyle and Jesse Howe

The Latest
An expected property tax bill around $11 million is well above what team leaders were hoping to pay as they weigh the possibilities of building a dome either in the suburbs or along Chicago’s lakefront.
White Sox notebook: Prelander Berroa, Zach DeLoach, Dominic Fletcher, Sox in the FAST lane
Candidate questionnaire to help you weigh your choices in the March 19, 2024 Illinois primary.
The trains could hit the rails as early as 2027 on the Rock Island line, potentially fast-tracking a move to greener service. One expert praised the purchase as a “major move” to address changing ridership habits.
The financial firm that employs 5,000 people in Riverwoods says the layoffs are unrelated to Capital One’s proposed $35 billion acquisition.