Editorial: Let’s hear what Judge Gorsuch has to say

SHARE Editorial: Let’s hear what Judge Gorsuch has to say

Judge Neil Gorsuch speaks to the crowd as his wife, Maria Louise, looks on after U.S. President Donald Trump nominated him to the Supreme Court during a ceremony in the East Room of the White House in January. | Alex Wong/Getty Images

Follow @csteditorials

Hold a hearing. Vet the nominee. Take a vote.

Senate Democrats should be wary of trying to block the confirmation of Judge Neil M. Gorsuch, President Donald Trump’s pick for the Supreme Court, as political payback even before the vetting process begins.

Without a doubt, Republicans in the Senate stole this seat on the Court, refusing for almost a year to do their duty and consider President Barack Obama’s nominee, Merrick Garland. Judge Garland was superbly qualified and should be on the court today.

EDITORIAL Follow @csteditorials

But there’s a good argument that Republicans, who hold a majority in the Senate, would simply do away with the right to filibuster if Democrats resorted to that tactic to block Gorsuch’s confirmation. The GOP then would confirm Gorsuch by a simple majority of 51 votes instead of 60. And what then? It is scary to even contemplate what kind half-baked nominee Trump might put up to fill the next seat that opened up on the Court, knowing he would need only a simple Senate majority to get his way.

This is not a strategy for Senate Democrats to give up the fight, but to do their job in a way their GOP colleagues never did. Put Gorsuch on the hot seat while keeping an open mind. Grill him on his originalist judicial philosophy, his views on the separation of powers in federal government, his views on abortion and Roe v. Wade, and a host of other issues.

For that matter, we’d love to know what Gorsuch thinks about Trump’s executive order banning people from seven largely Muslim countries from entry into the United States. The order is arguably unconstitutional in several ways, beginning with the exception carved out for people who are members of a non-majority religion. Who are, that is to say, Christian.

On this issue and others, Gorsuch could prove an obstacle to the most un-American parts of Trump’s agenda — or so we can hope. Gorsuch is a staunchly conservative justice in the Antonin Scalia mold. That puts him well within the Republican mainstream but does not make him an entirely safe bet for Trump.

Gorsuch is widely respected in legal circles, across the political spectrum, as a serious scholar committed to the rule of law. Trump, on the other hand, has show himself to be a man and a president who cares little about the law or the Constitution. He cares about winning.

We predict this judge and this president will never be soulmates.

It’s worth noting that Gorsuch already has signaled skepticism about the broadness of presidential power. In a 2016 opinion, he argued that the courts should not defer to federal agencies, which are extensions of the executive branch, when it comes to interpreting vague and ambiguous laws. That’s a view of bureaucratic rule-making that could create headaches for Trump-appointed agency heads.

Judge Gorsuch deserves the full and honest confirmation hearing that Judge Garland never got. Let’s hear what he has to say.

Send letters to letters@suntimes.com

Follow the Editorial Board on Twitter: @csteditorials

Tweets by @CSTeditorials

The Latest
Julianne Moore, Sebastian Stan head up brilliant cast of slick thriller set in New York.
The real story is not parents’ rights versus student privacy. It is transphobia versus trans existence.
As they prepare to elect their next mayor, city voters chose crime and public safety as the top issue guiding their decisions — and a whopping 63% of them don’t feel safe, a Sun-Times/WBEZ/Telemundo Chicago/NBC5 Poll found. But differences of opinions emerged among voters of different racial backgrounds.
Seats in the middle sections of auditoriums will cost an additional dollar or two, while seats in the front row will be slightly cheaper, the theater chain announced.