Polling Place: OK, critics, here are your selections of the best baseball movies ever

Why are there so many good ones? Not that anybody’s complaining.

SHARE Polling Place: OK, critics, here are your selections of the best baseball movies ever
Film location for the movie “Field of Dreams”

The “Field of Dreams” movie site in Dyersville, Iowa.

Photo by Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

“Dad . . . you want to have a catch?’’

You don’t need anybody to tell you what classic baseball film that line is from because you already know the answer. Just like you do in the cases of “Jusssst a bit outside,” “God, I love baseball,” “There’s no crying in baseball” and a whole lot of others.

In this week’s “Polling Place” — your home for Sun-Times sports polls on Twitter — we focused on baseball flicks, inspired by the Cubs’ trip to the “Field of Dreams” site in Dyersville, Iowa, to take on the Reds.

So, which baseball movie is your favorite?

“For sheer character variety and entertainment value, ‘Major League’ is the GOAT,” @TFroehlig commented. “It’s got everything an amazing story and script needs.”

You’ll see how we split up 12 baseball movies below. It was harder than we thought it would be to figure out which ones to include and how to group them for these polls, but, hey, that’s why we make the big bucks.

On to the polls:

Poll No. 1: You can pick only one, Heyday Division:

Upshot: Anybody else surprised by the ease with which “Major League” took this one? Some of us voted for “Bull Durham” and aren’t about to apologize for it. A great comment from @CubsSalty: “Putting ‘Bull Durham’ against ‘Major League’? Gonna ask me which kid is my favorite next?” We’d never put you on the spot like that, Salterino.

Poll No. 2: You can pick only one, Open Division:

Upshot:“The Sandlot” is charming and delightful, but is it really the best of these four or is it just the most recent? “I can’t believe ‘Sandlot’ is winning over ‘Bad News Bears,’ ” @MrSeanRoper wrote. “I will blame it on the Twitter generational divide.” That divide is real, people. Meanwhile, @ShawnaP79 tells no lies when she calls “A League of Their Own” “arguably one of the best baseball movies of all time.”

Poll No. 3: You can pick only one, Historical Division:

Upshot: Our print audience — a bit older than the average tweeter, we reckon — might disagree with the meager showing for a touching tribute to the great Lou Gehrig. These other stories, revolving around the 1919 Black Sox, Billy Beane and Jackie Robinson, were memorable watches, too. Why are there so many good baseball movies? Not that anybody’s complaining.

The Latest
The entire city is aiming at their backs. The McCaskeys and Kevin Warren sitting back on some Al Capone vibe waiting on when to give the order. Fire v. Fired. Same thing.
Counsell has yet to step in the dugout for the Cubs, but it’s becoming clear what the team should expect.
Crevier’s unrestrained happiness about being in the NHL — and underdog journey (as a 2020 seventh-round pick) to get to it — gives the Hawks something to smile about during an otherwise dispiriting stretch of the season.
Bent on redemption after collapsing in a 31-26 loss to the Lions at Ford Field on Nov. 19 — “the worst feeling after a loss we’ve had, ” safety Eddie Jackson said — the Bears’ defense has a chance to get it right and make a statement against a playoff-bound team.