Interactive graphic: Jay Cutler vs. the franchise quarterbacks

SHARE Interactive graphic: Jay Cutler vs. the franchise quarterbacks

Is Jay Cutler a franchise quarterback?

That’s the big question Phil Emery will have to decide in the coming months. By now, we all know there are three options:

  • Slap the franchise tag on him (According to’s Albert Breer, theprojected franchise-tag number for a quarterback in 2014 will be $16.2 million.
  • Sign him to a long-term deal.
  • Cut ties with Cutler and let him sign elsewhere.

Whatever the outcome, one thing is for sure — next season, he’ll be commanding similar money to the top five quarterbacks in the NFL. But do his stats warrant such a thing?

According to, the top-paid quarterbacks in 2013 (based on salary cap hit) are:

  • Eli Manning, $20,850,000
  • Matthew Stafford, $17,820,000
  • Peyton Manning, $17,500,000
  • Drew Brees, $17,474,000
  • Tom Brady, $13,800,000

Here’s how Cutler compares to these “franchise” quarterbacks this year (and yes, we know it’s a bit ridiculous to include Eli Manning in here based on his stats, but we have to based on the contract):

NFL games are won and lost in the fourth quarter, and Jay “Mr. Fourth Quarter” Cutler compares extremely favorably:

How about engineering a come-from-behind win? A look at how they play when trailing:

And then there’s that whole red zone offense, where Cutler has been prone to throw an interception.

The success of a season can largely rest in how December plays out. Here’s how Cutler’s December numbers stack up since 2010:

But then there’s the postseason numbers, where he’s only a step ahead of Detroit’s Matthew Stafford:

The Latest
Team says Kopech will be ready for spring training without restrictions
A boy, 14, and a man, 19, were shot about 6:20 p.m. Saturday in Greater Grand Crossing. Both were hospitalized in good condition, police said.
Go ahead, get excited. This is the best Illinois team since the Ron Zook years.
With roughly a week left until the opening NHL roster will be decided, Alec Regula, Alex Vlasic and Isaak Phillips remain on the bubble, likely fighting for two open spots.
Fritz Pollard was the first Black head coach in the NFL, one of the first two Black players in the NFL, the first Black football player at Brown University and the first Black player in the Rose Bowl.