$1M awarded to man wrongly accused of armed robbery

SHARE $1M awarded to man wrongly accused of armed robbery
JUDGEGAVEL_999x647.jpg

$1 million

The wrongful prosecution of a man who spent two years in jail awaiting trial for an armed robbery he didn’t commit has cost the city $1 million.

The money was awarded Wednesday to Jermaine Durdin, 24, by a Cook County jury and will come at the expense of the city and one of the investigating detectives, court records show.

In the initial complaint filed in Cook County Circuit Court in February 2013, Durdin alleged that the detective and three other officers “manipulated and/or tampered with identification evidence” that ultimately led to armed robbery charges to be filed against him.

Durdin’s attorney, Bill Foutris, said his client spent 23 months in the Cook County Jail before his trial. The only evidence against Durdin, Foutris said, was that he was picked out of a photo array and then a lineup. In May 2012, he was found not guilty.

The three officers who were initially named as defendants with the detective were found to have committed no wrongdoing, records show.

Bill McCaffrey, a spokesman for the city’s Law Department, said the jury’s award likely stemmed from poor instructions and that the city plans to appeal.

“While we are disappointed in the jury’s decision, we believe it was the result of erroneous jury instructions, as well as other legal errors, and we intend to file a motion seeking a new trial,” McCaffrey said in an email Wednesday night.

Court records show that since the 2012 verdict, Durdin has been arrested several more times on charges that include gambling, reckless conduct and possession of a controlled substance.

The court awarded Durdin $300,000 for “The loss of normal life experienced and reasonably certain to be experienced in the future”; $50,000 for pain and suffering; and $650,000 for “The emotional distress experienced and reasonably certain to be experienced in the future.”

The detective who was found to be at fault could not be reached for comment Wednesday night.

The Latest
Isaac Lambert has sued city, CPD claiming he was demoted for refusing to cover for a fellow officer who shot an unarmed, disabled teen in 2017.
Pritzker announced the state had reached a deal via the agreed bill process to contribute $1.8 billion and add $450 million as an interest-free loan to the Unemployment Insurance Trust Fund. Lawmakers are in Springfield for the fall veto session — and changes to the massive criminal justice package known as the SAFE-T Act are still anticipated.
The charges come more than a year after a federal grand jury subpoenaed the agency in May 2021 seeking records on Mustafaa Saleh and two dozen properties the land bank obtained and sold.
Mike Ruemmler, who managed Rahm Emanuel’s 2015 mayoral reelection campaign, said he plans to form a committee bankrolled by business leaders to elect moderate alderpersons.
Nick Fuentes was condemned Tuesday by the top two Republican leaders in Congress, Mitch McConnell and Kevin McCarthy — though McCarthy continued to defend President Donald Trump for meeting with him.